Is it necessary for defense lawyers to believe that the clients they defend are innocent of the charges against them. βββ
Question Β·
Must defense lawyers believe in their clientsβ innocence?
ββββ βββββ ββββββββ ββββ ββββ ββββββββ ββββ ββββββββββ ββ ββ βββββββ βββ ββββ βββββββ ββββ βββ βββββββ βββ ββββββββ ββββ ββ ββββββββββ βββββββββ βββ ββββββ βββββββ ββ ββββββ βββ ββββββββ ββ βββ ββββ ββββββββ βββββ βββββββββββββββ ββββ βββββ ββββ βββββββ ββββ ββ βββββ ββ βββββ ββββββββββ βββββββ ββ ββ βββ βββ ββ βββ ββββββ ββ βββββββββ βββββ ββ βββββββββ βββ βββ βββ ββ βββ ββββββ ββ βββββββββ βββ βββββββββ ββββββ βββ ββββββ ββββ βββββββ ββββ βββ ββββββββ ββββββββββββββ ββ ββ βββββ βββββ βββββ ββββ ββββ ββββββ ββββ ββββββββ βββββ βββββββββ βββββ βββββββββ βββββ ββ βββββ ββββββ βββ ββββββββ βββββ ββ βββ βββββββββ ββ ββββββββ ββββββββ βββββββββ ββ βββββ βββββββββ βββ ββββββββ ββββ ββ βββ ββ βββββββ ββ βββ ββ ββββββββ ββββββββ βββ ββ βββ ββ ββ βββββββββ ββββββ ββββ ββββ ββββββββββ βββββ βββ ββ ββββ βββββββββ βββ ββββββ ββββββββ ββ βββββββββ ββββ βββββ ββ βββββββββ βββββββββββ
Legal Scholars Β·
No
Lawyer's only job is to provide the best defense possible. It's not their job to judge their clients. Their job is to advocate for their clients.
βββ ββββ β ββββββββ βββββββββ βββ ββββ ββββ βββ βββββββ ββββββββ ββββββββββ ββ ββββββββ ββ βββ ββββββββββ ββββββββββ βββ ββ ββββ ββ ββ βββ βββββ ββββ ββ ββββββββββ ββ ββββββββ βββ ββββ βββββββ ββββββββ βββββ ββ βββββ ββββββββββ ββ ββββββββββ βββ ββββββ ββββ ββ ββββββββ ββ βββ ββββββ βββββββ ββ βββ βββββ ββββββββββ ββββ ββββ ββββ ββ ββ ββββββ βββ
Critique (of Legal Scholars) Β·
Lawyers have other obligations as well
Lawyers are officers of the court and hence have obligations (e.g., not lying) to the court.
βββ ββ βββ ββββ ββββββββββ βββββββ βββ βββ βββββββββ ββββ βββββ βββββββ βββ ββββββ ββββββ βββ βββββββββ ββ βββββββββββ βββββ ββββββββββ ββββββ ββββββββββ ββββββ βββ ββ ββββββββ ββ βββββ ββ βββββββββ βββββββββββββββ ββββ βββββββ ββββ ββββ βββββββββ ββββ β βββββββββ ββ βββββββ ββ ββ βββββ ββββ βββ ββ ββββ βββββ βββββββ ββββ ββββββ ββββββββ βββ ββββ ββ ββββ ββ ββββββββ ββ βββββ ββββββββ ββββββ βββββ ββββββ βββ βββββββββββββ ββ βββ βββββ ββ βββ βββββ βββββ βββ ββββ βββββββ βββ βββββββββββ βββββββββββββ βββ βββββ βββ ββββββββ ββββββ ββ ββββββββ ββ ββββββββββ ββββ βββββββββ βββββββ ββ ββββββββββ ββ βββββ βββββ ββ ββ βββββββββ βββββββ βββ ββββββ ββ ββββββ βββ βββ ββββββ βββββββββ ββββββββ βββ ββββββ βββ ββββ ββ βββββββββ βββ ββββββ ββββββ ββ ββββββ βββ ββ βββββ ββββ βββ ββββββ ββ βββββββββ
Critique Continued Β·
If a lawyer knows their client is guilty, then they should not deny this
They should not attempt to prove their innocence. Instead, make the best case for the client and argue for leniency.
βββ ββββββββ ββββββββββ ββ βββ βββββ βββ ββ βββββββ ββββ ββββββββββ ββββββββ βββ ββββββββββ βββββββ βββ βββββ ββββββββ βββ ββββ βββββ ββ ββββββββ ββ ββ ββββββββ ββββ βββββ β βββββββ ββββββββ ββ βββ ββββββ ββ βββββββββ ββ βββ ββββββ ββ βββ βββββ βββ ββββ ββββ βββββ ββββββ ββ ββββββββ ββ β βββββββ ββββ βββ ββββ ββββ βββββββ βββββββ ββββββ ββββ βββββ ββββ ββββ βββ ββββββββ βββββββ ββββββ βββ ββ ββββ βββββββββββ βββ β βββββββββ βββ βββββββ βββββββββ βββ βββ ββββββ ββ βββ βββββββββ βββββ βββ βββββ ββ βββ βββββ
Critique Continued Β·
Lawyer's obligation to the court and society ultimately benefits the defendant too
The defendant deserves a lawyer who truly believes in their innocence. Lawyers can simply refuse cases where they don't believe in their clients' innocence.