Nick agrees with this, but Pedro doesn’t necessarily disagree. Pedro clearly thinks that loyalty shouldn’t be a consideration in this particular decision, but he may still think it should be considered in other business decisions.

Neither speaker makes this claim. Neither Nick nor Pedro brings up the Pincus family’s intentions when making donations, so we can’t know if they agree or disagree.

Nick agrees with this, but Pedro disagrees, so this is their disagreement. Nick argues that accepting donations means the university is obligated to be loyal to the donors. Pedro states that donations do not carry any special privileges.

Neither Nick or Pedro states an opinion about this. The speakers are only talking about one particular long-time donor; they never make a comparison with more recent donors.

Neither speaker actually expresses a position on this point. First, Nick doesn’t talk about competition at all. Second, Pedro talks about competition but doesn’t make a claim about which bid was most competitive or whether the university chose right.