- Joined
- Nov 2025
- Subscription
- Free
Admissions profile
Discussions
correct me if I'm wrong but I just re-mapped this in review. originally I chose A and I see now why this is wrong. So here was my new map to explain each answer.
Forgive the extensive work here this is a level 5 question and my brain refuses simplicities.
If someone sees errors in my updated work please let me know!
Stimulus:
(Premises:)
FTA-->/SeriousA
Celeb-->SeriousA
(Conclusion:)
I-->FTA-->/SeriousA-->/Celeb
(or for simplicity here)
if A(First time author)-->/B(not Serious Attention)
if C(Celeb)-->B(Serious Attention)
Since A(FTA) then /B(not Serious Attention) because /C(not Celeb)
Answer Choices
(A) if A-->/B
if C-->B
Since C Then B
(B) if A-->/B (/B=not exciting=boring for simplicity sake)
If C-->B (B=exciting=not boring again for simplicity)
Since A also has /C then /B
or also read as
Since A then /B because /C (This is the correct answer)
(C)If A-->B (and i stopped there)
(D)if A-->B unless /A -->/B but C (this one was a little bizarre to read in context) (A=surviving spouse, B=Estate to spouse, C=estate to kids)
(E) If A-->/B
Since A-->/B must have been true.
When the word "No" is seen at the beginning of an answer choice, box it off, and read the rest "No celestial object that has no lithium in its atmosphere is a brown dwarf." Write it as "(No) Celestial object that has no lithium in its atmosphere is a brown Dwarf" This reads as /L-->/BD Then create the contra-positive (BD-->L). Since the final line on the Stimulus states "A brown dwarf does not have a fully functional nuclear furnace and so its lithium cannot be consumed." This tells us a brown dwarf must have lithium. Also Phrased as (if brown dwarf then lithium) or as we see here (BD-->L).
I got this wrong and sat here for an hour trying to understand it. Basically all the translation rule wants us to do is move the first "No" in the sentence and put it before the necessary. "(No) Celestial object that has no lithium in its atmosphere is a brown Dwarf" --> "Celestial object that has no lithium in its atmosphere is (No) a brown Dwarf" and if you want to make it ultra grammatically correct, you make it say "not" instead of "no". "if no lithium, then not brown Dwarf." then contra "if Brown Dwarf, then lithium."
Every time I write it out this way it seems so obvious but that double negation just sucks so incredibly bad, I accidentally read it as /L-->BD by writing it as "Any Celestial object that has lithium in it's atmosphere can not be a brown dwarf" and messed up my translation. facepalm I wasn't even timed and still made that mistake even after looking at it for almost 8 minutes.
It was my only wrong answer on a 12 question drill and one of the 2 questions on it that were level 5
After noticing what people are saying about C and believing it to be a possible answer, here is just my point of view.
The stimulus states "a number of Grandville's wealthiest citizens have been criminals"
some questions to ask here "how strong is the language?" and "does a number mean some, most, all, or none?"
Then the stimulus continues "Since it is of utmost importance that the Grandville Planning Committee be composed solely of individuals whose personal standards of ethics are beyond reproach, no wealthy person should be appointed to that committee"
Here we establish "if criminal, then /appoint" which also contains our conclusion.
Now the question stem asks "The argument is most vulnerable to the criticism that it" in other words, what is the biggest issue in what the author said.
Now ACs
A: This is not relevant to our conclusion. The author doesn't tell us what's sufficient for any result of appointment. Only what is sufficient to be a bad candidate
B: "Temporal" stop reading here. not relevant in this one
C: Similar to A in the sense that it is talking about the wrong thing and that is why it's wrong. It's pointing at "assumes that because a certain action (being a criminal) has a certain result (having these bad qualities) that action intended that result." This is not relevant as now we are forgetting about the fact that some of them are rich, intentions or not.
D: "subjective" stop there. It says the committee carries this with high importance, the standards will be objective.
E: Correct. Remember when I mentioned strength in the language? "a number" only a small logical jump needs to be made here. Pretend "a number" is equal to 5 people. And pretend there are 100 wealthy people in Grandville. No wealthy person when only 5 of them are actually bad? that sounds like a generalization on a possible set of exceptions.
I hope this makes sense
So this took me a really long time to get a hold of. 4/5 on the first attempt and 5/5 on Blind Review. To get used to it, the real goal is find the quick negation of all the answer choices, then it becomes more like a weakening question in the sense of needing to find the answer (when negated) that most butchers the argument, its hard to describe but I sat here for hours getting wrong answer after wrong answer and now here I am at the drill with most and then all of them correct. for those of you who are struggling like I am right now, I know we got this, even if my pt score hasn't passed over 150 in nearly 2 months. I'm holding out and hopefully my next pt is a marked improvement.
Okay so here is my issue. The reason I did not choose D was because I felt as though it was becoming oddly circular. So if the Modern Tree-Dwelling Kangaroos evolved from a species of land dwelling, then they moved forward in evolution. By modern science we can pretty easily conclude then that natural selection would weed out the ones who lacked the advantageous traits and keep the kangaroos with the most beneficial genes. Thus to say that they are losing these traits because of a previous common ancestor not having them seems irrelevant. rather than it sounding like "my great grandfather will be my child's great great grandfather" as someone put it, it sounds a lot more like "my 16th great grandfather will be my 16th cousin's 16th great grandfather." There's so much variation and difference there, that to call it like that is a bit absurd. My 16th cousin I can almost guarantee is not similar to me, and realistically I doubt either of us are even closely similar to our 16th great grandfather. To say that one of us would just suddenly regress to looking like the 16th great is a wild chance. The genetic similarity might be possible sure but the odds of that are practically 0%. this is an incredibly far reach.
Personally I chose C. because even though some of you seem to believe it doesn't do much my thought process here is "if they have a trait that can compensate for the lack of the other 2 traits, then it is not necessary for them to have the other 2 and thus may lose them."
If my reasoning seems unsound or uncertain please let me know!