@AleshaneeWebb That's a great way to think of it!

I believe Disney is the strongest argument because it has the evidence and a supporting argument that can be inferred from it. This contains a premise, conclusion, and a support.

The trash bin argument is the weakest because it can't be inferred that Mr. Fat Cat intentionally knocked over the bin to access the fish within just because he was on the counter cleaning himself -- that is a weak claim.

The argument of tigers is also a strong argument, containing both a premise and a conclusion. Although, what would make it stronger is maybe a support that further highlights the conclusion.