Stronger arguments tend to have more explicit premises.

Tiger: Not all soccer players are fast. Tina ran a 1 minute 50m dash

Mickey: Dani won the raffled item at the fair. The two wAYs to win were to buy a raffle ticket or make a donation. Dani did not buy a raffle ticket so she won the item by making a donation.

Trash bin: The shirt I was supposed to return was missing from my closet and returned with it hanging with the hanger facing the door. Only my roommate hangs her close with the hook facing the door. Therefore my roomate must have been the one to take my missing shirt.