HamedShahabi
- Joined
- Jun 2025
- Subscription
- Core
Admissions profile
LSAT
Not provided
Goal score: 180
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
Not provided
Discussions
HamedShahabi
Saturday, Nov 1, 2025
This still doesn't make sense to me. When I read C to me the other areas that its comparing too don't have the soot. So its at least as higher as all the other areas but that doesn't imply that it is higher. in the weakest form on the AC the frequency is equal between a city with the soot and without the soot. How does that weaken the stimulus?
HamedShahabi
Tuesday, Jul 29, 2025
I still dont see how its B -- JY keeps saying you need Y AND Z but nowhere in the stimulus does it lay the logic for the AND. It only says that you need to be run down physically. The AND he keeps referring to is just made up nowhere to be found in the stimulus unless I'm missing something.
Really lost here lol.
No one can ever convince me this is a well written question - quite possibly the worst one I've ever taken. Because no where in the stimulus does Demos read it silently - he looks at it with amazement - that's all we know - he could've read it silently with amazement or out load with amazement. The next sentence has no bearing on his first action - whereupon "explains" can be interpreted not him reading the prophecy but simply explaining the implications or anything other than reading it out loud- and to take it sequentially where he didn't read it out loud then he did when he was asked is not a inference one can reasonably make.
Then the more obvious gap in the answer choice, is that we are taking a scene in a play - this play can be performed legit 1000 years later, and then applying it to ancient Greece itself. Its a play, not real life, the play can be fiction, and it doesn't have to have any resemblance to what life was like in ancient Greece. Then JY in the explanation says because he explains it in the second half, we can infer he read it in the first part, yes well no shit sherlock. But did he read it silently? there is not a single indication that he did. Him looking at it with amazement doesn't tell us whether it was out loud or slient.