Hi there,
My name is Carl, and I've been tutoring the LSAT since the early 2000s, online and in person. These days I mostly work online over Zoom.
I would never tell someone that it's impossible to self-study for the test or that a tutor is absolutely required, by any means. I would say, however, that having the right guidance at the right moment in your studies can both save you a lot of frustration and streamline the process of improving your score. I can guide you from the beginning of your studies or step in as a troubleshooter when you hit a sticking point. I can take a look at the work you've done recently and try to diagnose what's holding you back and provide you with a recommendation of the best next steps to take in the short term and in the long term.
Two people scoring in the 170s might tackle the test in completely different ways. My job as a tutor is not to turn you into a carbon copy of me, but to help you find the combination of techniques and methods that will get you the score you want. Sure, there are certainly some required skills on the test--some questions are impossible, for example, if you don't know what a contrapositive is. But there's also a lot of leeway. There's no one-size-fits-all approach, and I tailor my lessons to you and your needs.
I specialize in helping people move the needle who've been stuck on a plateau for a long time. I also offer a free one-hour evaluation session to all potential clients, an hour for us to meet, discuss your troubles, have me demonstrate my tutoring style, and have you ask any questions you have. So, please, reach out if you'd like to schedule an evaluation with me to see if I can help you.
My personal lawyer likes to say, 'You take the best move on the board. It doesn't matter if you'd prefer another move. If it's off the board, it's off the board.'
It seems, from this consultant's advice, 'apply early and get accepted' is off the board for you. So it's time to look at what the best move left might be. 'Apply late with a better score' is probably the best move left on the board. Don't worry that this move isn't as good as 'apply early'. 'Apply early' is off the board--if this consultant is right.
I put 'if this consultant is right' there for a reason. You might be getting bad advice. But it's not impossible that your consultant is right. A low enough score does mean straight to the reject pile, no matter what schools may say.
If the consultant is telling you that when you have a 4.0, and the consultant is worth consulting, that means that LSAT score must be pretty bad. If it's that bad, surely, you can improve it with time. The consultant might not be an expert on how long it takes to improve a score from pretty bad to OK enough. It might not be a year. But they're probably correct that you do need to improve. (Unless you just found a terrible consultant.)