- Joined
- 6 days ago
- Subscription
- Live
Admissions profile
Discussions
Hi all! I had a question regarding the "skill builder: arguments" section of the lesson library.
Here, we say that the following is not an argument:
Human communication is a universal phenomenon that has existed across different civilizations over time. Linguists have conducted many comparative analyses of traditional languages from various regions and eras.
To me, however, I initially rejected the soundness of the passage's "argument"—mainly because the first sentence uses "universal," which is too strong of a qualifier—based on the second sentence. However, for linguists to conduct comparative analyses on traditional languages from various regions and eras directly implies that human communication is a phenomenon (even if not universal) that has existed across different civilizations over time.
I asked Sage AI, and it said the passage would be an argument if it were to directly tie the sentences together with a connecting word, such as "therefore":
Linguists have conducted many comparative analyses of traditional languages from various regions and eras (premise). Therefore, human communication is a phenomenon—even if not necessarily universal—that has existed across different civilizations over time (conclusion).
Maybe I'm overthinking this, but I wanted to set my logical reasoning straight before trying to dive into the other passages. Thanks!