User Avatar
MustStudyMore
Joined
Apr 2025
Subscription
Free

Admissions profile

LSAT
Not provided
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
Not provided

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT141.S2.Q25
User Avatar
MustStudyMore
Friday, Jul 14, 2023

What a stupid question. I was trying to map out the claims using logic/lawgic since the question stem said "most logically...", but this argument is not logically sound at all

8
PrepTests ·
PT142.S1.Q18
User Avatar
MustStudyMore
Wednesday, Jul 12, 2023

J.Y. glosses over AC in E in this question way too quickly.

The conclusion being advanced says, in part, that "this shows mild sleep deprivation is not unhealthy."

Because of this, it is 100% reasonable to think that a flaw in this argument is that the author is concluding that mild sleep deprivation doesn't cause illness and then extrapolating the lack of causing an illness to mean that sleep deprivation isn't unhealthy at all (e.g. maybe it causes physical ailments. If that was the case, sleep deprivation would still be unhealthy even though it doesn't cause illness).

Nevertheless, here is why E isn't correct: E says, in part "even if a negative consequence is not associated with a given phenomenon..." i.e. even if illness is not associated with minor sleep deprivation. The author never said that though! The author never says that sleep deprivation is not associated with any illness.

Instead, the author said "there was a greater frequency of illness among those who regularly slept at least 8 hours a night than among those who slept significantly less," i.e. that people who slept 8+ hours are more likely to be sick than those who slept less.

The key distinction is this:

Answer E describes the author's premise as: sleep deprivation is not associated with illness.

In reality, the author's premise is: sleep deprivation is not as frequently associated with illness as over sleeping.

Answer choice E is wrong because is improperly characterizes the authors argument.

68

Confirm action

Are you sure?