i think so, but I don’t really get what the “innocent people” thing is doing there in the first place. It seems to imply that if the workers weren’t innocent then them getting sick would be alright because they’re bad people or something, which doesn’t really follow from what’s in the stimulus

Jane practices longsword fencing. German style longsword fencing is more effective in competition than Italian longsword. Jane recently took gold at a tournament. Therefore, she must practice german longsword.

Weak(ish) support: while conclusion is plausible based on the evidence, it is far from definitive. After all, saying one thing is more effective doesn't mean the other thing is ineffective