I'm interested!

Disney is probably strong because the premises offer 2 options, one of which is eliminated, leaving us with what we think is only one option. Tiger is second because the argument uses a true example. Trash Bin is the weakest because while it does offer a lot of evidence pointing to one direction, it doesn't give us a definitive option like Disney or use a true example like tiger.

This was my line of thinking, but please let me know if I missed anything!!!

Tiger: Not all cars are red. After all, red is the color least in demand from manufacturers.

Trashcan: Angela ran out of shampoo while in the shower, and Jessica is acting suspiciously. Jessica and Angela also use the same type of shampoo. Therefore, Jessica must have used all of Angela's shampoo.

Disney: Band members play a wind, brass, or percussion instrument. All other members are color guard. Since Ally does not play any instrument, yet is still a band member, she must be a color guard.