User Avatar
jfinley
Joined
Jun 2026
Subscription
Live

Admissions profile

LSAT
161
CAS GPA
3.19
1L START YEAR
2027

Applications

Loyola Marymount - LA
Intend to apply
Pepperdine
Intend to apply
Southwestern
Intend to apply
UCLA
Applied
USC
Intend to apply

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT148.S4.Q11
User Avatar
jfinley
Wednesday, Nov 11

At first I was of the opinion that this question should have been removed from scoring...

But then I took a step back and just imagined that I was sitting down with the university spokesperson and they were presenting this argument to me. Like as if I were the university administrator who would sign off on this decision or something.

If I were presented with this line of reasoning, I would be like "Wait, do the students know that Hall Dining is the only alternative option?" At the end of the day, the flaw presented in the correct AC is a legitimate flaw even though it doesn't seem to me to be a cookie cutter question or a classic flaw.

I'm going to try to employ this "envisioning strategy" on future questions too.

1
User Avatar
jfinley
Edited Tuesday, Nov 10

that's awesome! congrats!

2
PrepTests ·
PT108.S3.Q18
User Avatar
jfinley
Wednesday, Aug 19

This question makes my head spin

3

Confirm action

Are you sure?