Even if I take premises one through seven to be true; the argument assumes Walt obtains their Genie+ pass after having become a member of the Disney Vacation Club. Additionally, the argument is silent as to whether other "groups" of persons exists other than the "all other members" group of persons that themselves may have an eligibility route to obtaining a Genie+ pass.

The second issue I raised reminds me of the "Fat Cat" argument where a deficiency concerning an additional group's existence: "Other pets present who could have done this..." was identified.

Does the argument not become decidedly weaker as a result of these deficiencies?

#feedback

#help

Hoping to join if the invitation remains open!