I'm having trouble conceptualizing the inherent flaw in answer choice B (and other versions of it that show up in other questions). I didn't pick it, but I keep getting tempted by answers that go something along the lines of "X should only happen when Y," with Y being the premise(s) in the stimulus. In my mind, the phrase "manufacturers should be held responsible only for the preventable consequences of their actions" feels inclusive of the situation in the stimulus?

I understand what JY is saying in the video, but I can't get the logic of why it's "backwards" to stick in my head. Does anyone else have a framework/way to think about it that they find more intuitive?