User Avatar
mkgcpinoy411
Joined
Apr 2025
Subscription
Free

Admissions profile

LSAT
Not provided
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
Not provided

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT123.S2.Q16
User Avatar
mkgcpinoy411
Saturday, Jul 26 2014

I'm going to have to agree. That question implies what opinion of TAYLOR's that SANDRA would disagree with.

"...the most support for holding that Sandra would disagree with Taylor about which of the following statements?"

Alright, I'm in the mindset of finding which of the multiple choice answers, if it coincides with an opinion that Taylor has, as illustrated in the text, that Sandra would disagree with.

This would lead me to choose C. The answer is making a direct claim that precision is impossible in said area of a study of science, which is contradictory to Sandra's belief that precise results are possible, though she shares no particular opinion on the subject mentioned, the context given implies that she is uncomfortable with any claims invalidating a scientific measurement indefinitely on the pretense that precise measurements are to be taken at an arms lengths.

JY, I understand now what the questions was intending to ask; that the disagreement be either "yes" or "no" by any party, but if that was in fact the intention, it would have been more accurate to ask, "The statements above provide the most support for holding that Sandra and Taylor would disagree about which one of the following statements?"

Otherwise, it is completely misleading.

Will questions in future LSAT's often be structured in such a way?

1

Hello!

I'm fresh off the boat on 7Sage and I'm wanting to take full advantage of the "study buddies" feature. I would be perfectly content with just an online partner but if there was anyone fairly close to Parkersburg or Vienna, West Virginia that would be even better!

Thanks!

0

Confirm action

Are you sure?