Hi All,
https://classic.7sage.com/lsat_explanations/lsat-18-section-2-question-07/
I was between B and C for this question and was hoping folks could weigh in on why C was wrong. I did listen to JY's explanation but still have some hesitations for getting rid of C. Here's the overview:
Context: Scientists are said to assume that something is not the case until there is proof that it is the case
Conclusion: The characterization (above) of scientists is false.
Premise: In evaluating a question of whether an unresearched additive is safe, scientists would say the following based on the characterization:
1. The additive is unsafe because it has not been proven to be safe
2. The additive is safe because it has not been proven to be unsafe.
Premise 2 : No scientist can assume without contradiction that a given substance is both safe and unsafe.
My Pre-phrase: Argument shows that taking a statement to be true results in a contradiction, so the statement cannot be true.
Answer Choice B: A statement is argued to be false by showing that taking it to be true leads to implausible consequences.
My Thoughts: I circled this upon first reading it but wasn't crazy about the word implausible, which I read as unlikely or not probable. If they would have given me something more like illogical, I would never have read on.
Answer Choice C: A statement is shown to be false by showing that it directly contradicts a second statement that is taken to be true.
My Thoughts: I read this as...a statement (ie the context) is shown to be false by showing that it directly contradicts a second statement (Premise 2) that is taken to be true. JY's explanation stated that there was no second statement, which seemed to me to exist. I can throw it out for not being a "direct" contradiction since the contradiction is in the application...
Would love any feedback on C!
Honestly, I think they should all be black and 72 should have featured a casket on it :smile:
@ said:
I think the lovely diarrhea brown of PT 75 is by far the most appropriate color for any PT. Honestly, they should just start using the poop emoji as the cover for future PTs.
This is too funny. I just literally laughed out loud.