PT20.S1.Q10 - premiums for automobile

yeshesvini

https://7sage.com/lesson/flaw-questions-problem-set-12/
https://7sage.com/lsat_explanations/lsat-20-section-1-question-10/

For this qs, while it fits well into the classic causation correlation flaw category with AC c as the correct answer, i am unable to get past AC e for its equitable validity as an answer choice as well....

can anyone help me get past this road block in my head please...

thanks heaps!

vini

btate87

I see where you're coming from with the stimulus line "lives could undoubtedly be saved." However, E goes way too far in describing the substance of the stimulus. The author could simply be referring to 10% of accidents that result in a loss of life. The argument doesn't depend on every accident resulting in a fatality, therefore it can't be a flaw in the argument.

Hope that helps!