What does Columbia first reserve mean? Do they have second reserve?

Comments

• Relaxlsater Alum Member

  February 2018 10 karma

  nbd...
• acsimon Alum Member

  February 2018 1269 karma

  I don’t really think ppl are ghostin’ you. I just think that the ppl who saw this have no idea. I certainly don’t.—A.c.S
• Paul Caint Alum Member ⭐

  February 2018 3521 karma

  I'm "first reserve" also. I don't think there's a "second reserve." We are de-facto waitlisted, but Columbia calls it "reserve" since they don't rank kids like in some waitlists like "if this person says no to our offer, Paul is the next kid we want....if Paul says no, John is the next kid we want...etc." Instead, they re-review each person's application to see which ones they want to extend offers to in May.
• Relaxlsater Alum Member

  February 2018 10 karma

  Thank you both guys!
• Relaxlsater Alum Member

  February 2018 10 karma

  Just have the impression that CLS sent out so many Waitlists that they dun actually reject ppl lol
• 1 Like

  TabbyG123 Member

  February 2018 711 karma

  There is a first reserve, a second reserve, and a third reserve (you can event visit the URLs for these pages where you opt in to the reserve list!). They are listed not in order or hierarchy but strictly ordered by time/cycles. Here's how it works:
  1. If you are put on the reserve list from regular admissions, you are placed on first reserve to be reviewed at the end of May (once the school has heard back from their students admitted ED/RD).
  2. In the end of May, you are either accepted or rejected or placed on second reserve to be reviewed again in June, depending on the number of folks that accept or reject their ED/RD offer.
  3. Near the end of June, this second reserve pool goes through the process again: either rejected, accepted, or deferred again to the third reserve depending on the folks who accept/reject from the first reserve pool.
  4. Near the end of July, this third reserve pool goes through the process once again, except everyone is either rejected or accepted. There is no fourth reserve.

  I also got on first reserve at Columbia. :B Hoping to publish this paper I've been working on to show some recent accomplishments for my letter of continued interest. Best of luck!
• westcoastbestcoast Alum Member

  February 2018 3788 karma

  wow congrats on first reserve! curious about this question as well
• TheMikey Alum Member

  February 2018 4196 karma

  @PublicInterested said:
  There is a first reserve, a second reserve, and a third reserve (you can event visit the URLs for these pages where you opt in to the reserve list!). They are listed not in order or hierarchy but strictly ordered by time/cycles. Here's how it works:
  1. If you are put on the reserve list from regular admissions, you are placed on first reserve to be reviewed at the end of May (once the school has heard back from their students admitted ED/RD).
  2. In the end of May, you are either accepted or rejected or placed on second reserve to be reviewed again in June, depending on the number of folks that accept or reject their ED/RD offer.
  3. Near the end of June, this second reserve pool goes through the process again: either rejected, accepted, or deferred again to the third reserve depending on the folks who accept/reject from the first reserve pool.
  4. Near the end of July, this third reserve pool goes through the process once again, except everyone is either rejected or accepted. There is no fourth reserve.

  I also got on first reserve at Columbia. :B Hoping to publish this paper I've been working on to show some recent accomplishments for my letter of continued interest. Best of luck!

  didn't know this, thanks!
• Relaxlsater Alum Member

  February 2018 10 karma

  @PublicInterested said:
  There is a first reserve, a second reserve, and a third reserve (you can event visit the URLs for these pages where you opt in to the reserve list!). They are listed not in order or hierarchy but strictly ordered by time/cycles. Here's how it works:
  1. If you are put on the reserve list from regular admissions, you are placed on first reserve to be reviewed at the end of May (once the school has heard back from their students admitted ED/RD).
  2. In the end of May, you are either accepted or rejected or placed on second reserve to be reviewed again in June, depending on the number of folks that accept or reject their ED/RD offer.
  3. Near the end of June, this second reserve pool goes through the process again: either rejected, accepted, or deferred again to the third reserve depending on the folks who accept/reject from the first reserve pool.
  4. Near the end of July, this third reserve pool goes through the process once again, except everyone is either rejected or accepted. There is no fourth reserve.

  I also got on first reserve at Columbia. :B Hoping to publish this paper I've been working on to show some recent accomplishments for my letter of continued interest. Best of luck!

  @PublicInterested said:
  There is a first reserve, a second reserve, and a third reserve (you can event visit the URLs for these pages where you opt in to the reserve list!). They are listed not in order or hierarchy but strictly ordered by time/cycles. Here's how it works:
  1. If you are put on the reserve list from regular admissions, you are placed on first reserve to be reviewed at the end of May (once the school has heard back from their students admitted ED/RD).
  2. In the end of May, you are either accepted or rejected or placed on second reserve to be reviewed again in June, depending on the number of folks that accept or reject their ED/RD offer.
  3. Near the end of June, this second reserve pool goes through the process again: either rejected, accepted, or deferred again to the third reserve depending on the folks who accept/reject from the first reserve pool.
  4. Near the end of July, this third reserve pool goes through the process once again, except everyone is either rejected or accepted. There is no fourth reserve.

  I also got on first reserve at Columbia. :B Hoping to publish this paper I've been working on to show some recent accomplishments for my letter of continued interest. Best of luck!

  Thanks man! This is so clear, best of luck!