PT12.S4.Q13 - Police published a "wanted" poster for a criminal

wkim2015wkim2015 Alum Member
edited June 2018 in Logical Reasoning 86 karma

Can someone please be kind enough to explain to me why the answer is (c)? I was able to eliminate only (a) and (b). I thought (c), (d), and (e) were all valid. I think I am missing something here.. Please help! Thank you so much.

Admin note: edited title

Comments

  • FixedDiceFixedDice Member
    1804 karma

    PT12.S4.Q13***

  • FixedDiceFixedDice Member
    edited June 2018 1804 karma

    (D) is wrong because of "consent" and "required by medical treatment" (does treating a gunshot wound involve mandatory police report?). (E) is wrong because it would violate the given requirement regarding cops, who aren't involved in medical treatment of patients.

  • wkim2015wkim2015 Alum Member
    86 karma

    I'm sorry but I don't follow your explanation for why (d) is incorrect. Doesn't the passage say that treating a gunshot would must be reported?

  • FixedDiceFixedDice Member
    edited June 2018 1804 karma

    Medical treatment as in the process of treating a gunshot patient - sanitizing the wound(s), pulling out the bullet(s), etc. Do those operational procedures by themselves necessitate police involvement?

  • PearlyGoGoPearlyGoGo Alum Member
    171 karma

    Both (D) and (E) are not compatible with the requirement cited in the stimulus, which is the fact that physicians are already subject to report gunshot wounds and certain infectious diseases to health authorities. According to the stimulus, this exceptions is ethical. AC(D) and (E) would make this exception unethical, and this is not what question stem asked us to do.

  • akistotleakistotle Member ⭐ 🍌🍌
    edited June 2018 9382 karma

    Hi @wkim2015,

    If you write in the format of PT#.S#.Q# ("PT12.S4.Q13" for this question), the existing thread pops up when you try to make a thread:
    https://imgur.com/KACMJdS

    https://7sage.com/discussion/#/discussion/3194/pt12-s4-q13-police-published-a-wanted-poster-for-a-criminal-fugitive

    https://7sage.com/discussion/#/discussion/15/forum-rules

Sign In or Register to comment.