PT1.S3.Q25 - On the basis of their statements

SaraFromOCSaraFromOC Member
edited May 2019 in Logical Reasoning 148 karma

I put D as my answer to this question, but the correct answer is A. I don't understand why, since the stipulation for a work to be considered unique is for it to have historical or aesthetic value. How would that apply to an unflattering painting of someone's father?

Admin note: edited title

Comments

  • drbrown2drbrown2 Alum Member
    2227 karma

    Jorge just says unique artwork must be preserved. Aesthetic or historic belong to posterity is the premise supporting J’s conclusion that unique works must be preserved, not a stipulation.

    A describes a unique piece of art, so J would say the owner must preserve it despite not liking it and Shanna would say the owner can do whatever they want and destroy it if they wish.

    D talks about works of art that are not unique, which J says nothing about.

Sign In or Register to comment.