... a manner kind of like SufficientAssumption ACs, in that they fill ... choices are simply unstated premises necessary to the argument that defend ...
At any rate, sufficientassumption questions really require reading carefully ... , the right answer to the sufficientassumption question bridges a term shift ... , both subjects carry the same necessary condition ("ring-bearers" and apparently ...
... that is not helpful or necessary) at work in the choice ... reveals that quantification as the assumption needed in order to ... that gap in reasoning. The assumption JY and I have made ... weakness of the argument—for sufficientassumption, it’s better to quantify ...
Good thread! I was just wondering the same . Thank god to Sage at least now I know there is a difference between sufficient and necessaryassumption questions (didn't learn that in my over 1,000$ crappy test prep course).
... if the question was a sufficientassumption question I think that C ... 't need a sufficient condition, we just need a necessary condition that ... " and provides just what is necessary for the argument to hold ...
... recognize that there's some sufficient and necessaryassumption confusion because there's ... "treats a sufficientassumption as a necessaryassumption" and "treats a necessaryassumption as a sufficientassumption."
... or how little.
-For sufficientassumption, you need to figure out ... be sufficient to guarantee that the argument would work.
-For necessaryassumption ...
... lot of chapters dedicated to Assumption questions, so it clarified everything ... . I haven't missed a Necessary or SufficientAssumption question in 3 PTs ...
... required, or necessary, for the argument to obtain. A sufficientassumption questions asks ... we negate a necessary condition (in this case assumption) the sufficientassumption (In this ...
Hey LogicFiend! The necessary condition above seems more like ... truth table. Based on the assumption that NOT is similar logically ... not exist". That means the sufficientassumption that would prove our conclusion ...
... seem more like a necessaryassumption rather than a sufficientassumption? After reading your ... think it really is a sufficientassumption. In order for it to ... be sufficient, don't you need to ...
I agree that it's a sufficientassumption not necessary. I wasted extra time on this q when saw no answer choice that was a NA but this question seems flawed.
This is basically a conflating sufficient and necessary conditions flaw.
... Maybe it's a reasonable assumption that the chief of police ... think this is a safe assumption on the LSAT. Similarly, ... this isn't a safe assumption on the LSAT -- maybe ...
... you are giving is a SufficientAssumption. With the two premises, (one ... .
It's not a Necessaryassumption because, while the negation does ... much caffeine" limit.
A necessaryassumption always destroys the argument when ...
@Elle2015 If this were a necessaryassumption question, then I think you’d be on to something, employing the negation test. But this is a sufficientassumption question. So we need an answer that will make the argument valid.
... and can pick tiny little necessary assumptions that don't ... to be important to be necessary.
It doesn't ... and yet it's a necessaryassumption. If the opposite is true ... a Sufficientassumption, and guarantees the conclusion, but it's not necessary. Even ...
... of knowledge. Michiko adds the sufficient condition that “if they know ... sufficientassumption and conclude with the correctly corresponding necessaryassumption. So to trigger the sufficientassumption ...
... ), Necessaryassumption (identify the one assumption who's negation would destroy the argument), Sufficientassumption ... (identify the one assumption that when true would ...