Hi, I was wondering if anyone had any tips on weaken questions that involve correlation. I have gotten my LR down to a consistent -2/0 and the only questions I consistently miss are high level weaken questions that involve correlation. Whenever i see causal or correlative reasoning I by default start to look for answers that could give alternate explanations for the evidence provided, but i'm assuming that is not the best way since I keep getting them wrong.
4
3 comments
Hi there! While you're not wrong to look for alternative explanations, it sounds like you might be boxing yourself in to just that method and as a result, you're probably missing correct answers because they don't fit what you're expecting. With all pre-phrases, specific or vague, you always want to keep an open mind even when you're hunting for a specific answer. Especially on more difficult questions (which it sounds like are your struggle here), the answer might not be something that is easily pre-phraseable. In fact, I find that a lot of 4-5 star questions give you an obvious pre-phrase in the stimulus for one way to weaken, and then the answer choices ignore that obvious option completely and the correct answer is either much more obscure or super simple, but in a way where you'd never expect it.
Make sure you have a few other ideas in mind for general causal/correlation weakening. You can weaken the results of a study by pointing to a problem with how it was conducted (or showing that the sample is unrepresentative). You can show third factor causation, as you're already looking for, or reverse causation, etc. There are a bunch of ways to weaken, and a lot of 4-5 star questions might use answers that don't even fall into any of these categories!
So as you're doing targeted drilling to work on weaken questions, drill with a clear goal in mind: you're going to pre-phrase as normal/identify what you're expecting, but then you're going to let that go. Look through the answers with fresh eyes, keeping in mind that it would be nice to find your pre-phrase, but staying open to other answers. And if you think you find one you like, make sure it actually weakens. Trap answers on 4-5 star questions will often look like an alternate explanation, but they will actually not weaken at all (either they explain something we don't care about, or they're asking you to make unreasonable assumptions). Work through each question with a clear goal of setting aside your expectations and looking for the right, justifiable answer, not the one that feels closest to what you expect.
Do this for all difficult questions (and all questions in general), by the way! Pre-phrasing or honing in on one option is okay at first, but once you start to look at the answer choices you've got to stay open to alternatives, knowing that your prediction might not be in the answer choices at all (and a similar-looking wrong answer might be a trap choice). Clearly identifying what you expect and then setting that aside to look at answers should help you break out of that habit and improve on those 4-5 star Weaken questions. Hopefully this helps!
@Josephine Thank You!!!
Think of the three classic alternatives - coincidence, reversal, third factor. Don't assume its' alternative explanation. Are you testing answer choices by plugging them back in - evidence, then answer choice, then "am I still so sure about the conclusion?" Are you eliminating the right answer? Getting it down to two and then can't figure out which one is right?