Hey everyone, looking for some insight into a unique Character & Fitness (C&F) situation for this cycle.
I applied to law school last cycle but ended up sitting it out to improve my LSAT score. I'm reapplying this cycle to many of the same schools, but I realized I made a mistake on my previous applications regarding a C&F disclosure, and I'm stressed about how to handle the discrepancy.
Background: During the first fully online COVID semester, I was taking classes overseas and ran into severe internet connectivity issues. I had to withdraw from my courses, but because I was in an accelerated 8-week class, I had already missed the withdrawal deadline for that specific course. I couldn't complete the coursework or take the exam, resulting in an F.
Afterward, the school talked to me about the threat of academic probation and required me to take a mandatory student success/time-management class the next semester. I locked in, earned a 4.0 the following term, corrected the previous grades, and was explicitly told I was back in "good standing."
The Mistake: Because I was placed in that specific class and had the probationary talk, I was under the genuine impression that I had officially been on academic probation. When I applied last cycle, I checked "yes" to the academic discipline/probation question and wrote an addendum explaining the COVID connectivity issues.
The Discovery: While prepping my materials to reapply this cycle, I called my school and double-checked my official records and discovered I was never actually on official academic probation. It was just a serious administrative warning and a mandatory workshop.
My Dilemma: I am reapplying to the exact same schools. If I don't disclose it this year (since it isn't a reportable C&F issue based on my actual records), the admissions committees might compare my new applications to last year's and think I am hiding a C&F issue I previously admitted to.
How do I approach this?
Should I still check "no" and write a brief addendum explaining the discrepancy between the cycles?
Has anyone else had to "walk back" an over-disclosure?
Appreciate any advice or perspectives.
3 comments
Some schools will ask on C&F if you have ever been warned, while others will only ask if you were actually on probation. Depending on their prompt, you will have to disclose or not disclose! In the case of reapplying to a school where you now do not have to disclose, I would maybe write a super short addendum explaining the situation and that they can also request for a report from the university to confirm. It should be fine either way (and not all schools will reexamine an applicant's old application), but it could help for the schools that do. Alternatively, you can reach out to each school's admissions office and ask what they would recommend.
My honest suggestion is to contact the schools via phone and ask. You’re not the first to be in this kind of situation and every school will handle this differently so you just want to be careful.
For what it’s worth though, people over report matters on the CF section all the time. I really doubt that talking about this on your apps last year cost you. Or to put things another way - an F is a problem, explaining the F and the aftermath is not a problem.
I’m in the same spot! I plan on just checking “no” this year. I noticed some schools added a new section for academic warnings too. I didn’t want to add another addendum for them to review.
If they compare my applications and ask about the discrepancy, I plan on talking to them at that point about the misunderstanding!