Exotic art, cutting-edge science, ethnic music, and historical debates - whoever curates the RC section on the LSAT is trying their best to entrance and confuse you with elaborate details and obscure vocabulary. So it's no surprise that the majority of my 150s students, when asked to summarize a paragraph or passage, end up with an amalgamation of details, words, and half-baked arguments that aren't of much use when answering questions. So how can we fix this seemingly impossible problem? The passages just barely make any sense!
The answer is another question: Who's talking? Is it the author himself? Is the author quoting a researcher, a scientist, a musician? What does the author think about their position? And what do they think about the author's position?
Take the opening line of two real RC passages (slightly paraphrased):
"The zoologist Rohwer asserted that plumage variations in Harris sparrows support the status signaling hypothesis."
"Physicists are often asked why the image of an object appears reversed left-to-right when viewed in a mirror."
Neither of these is the author talking. One is Rohwer's claim being reported, and the other is a question that certain physicists get asked. And guess what? In both passages, within a few lines, the author shows their true feelings on the matter: "However, Rohwer's data do not support his assertions." "However, some physicists offer a completely different explanation."
If you summarize the first paragraph as a bunch of information, you walk into the questions assuming the quoted opinions are fact. But if you ask "who's talking?", then you can recognize, and even predict (as you develop the pattern recognition), the author's opinion. That will not only facilitate understanding the passage, but also give you the key to answering a number of questions.
By clearly mapping out the dialogue in the passage, weak arguments begin to look like logical attacks, unimportant details become supporting examples of positions, and the passage begins to take form - not as a bunch of words, but as a story, a progression.
In my eyes, this is part of what separates the middling students from the upper-tier, both in RC and in LR - can they take the sentences shown to them and create an argument? Can they see into the mind of the author? Because if they can, they'll also find the assumption, the flaw, and the principle.
So next time you read a passage, I recommend stopping after every paragraph and asking "Who said that - and what does the author think?". With this perspective, RC should stop feeling like a jungle and more like some trees (I don't actually know if that's a metaphor).
Good luck!
2 comments
Thanks for the advice, Andrew! Any tips are helpful to navigating through this jungle, you say. Cheers.
@Shannon-247 no problem shannon! any more questions feel free to reach out...it's a jungle out there for sure!