- Joined
- Oct 2025
- Subscription
- Core
Admissions profile
Discussions
Distinguishing Between Predicate-Object and Predicate-Modifier
Predicate object: Answers “what?” or “whom?” after the verb. It tells you what the action is directed toward.
The cat likes to drink milk
Subject: Cat
Predicate-Verb: likes
Predicate-Object: to drink milk
If you look at the phrase "likes to drink", you couldn't grammatically say "The cat likes" without the second part "to drink". “To drink milk” explains WHAT the “cat likes”. So those three words have to be tied together as a predicate.
Predicate-verb modifier: Answers “how?”, “when?”, “where?”, or “why?” It provides additional information about the action.
Strong antibiotics fail to kill the bacteria that live in deep wounds.
Subject: Antibiotics
Predicate-Verb: fail
Predicate-Modifier: to kill
When you look at "fail to kill", technically you could say The antibiotics fail. The modifier, "to kill", is necessary to explain WHY it fails at and complete the thought. Remember sometimes we do need the modifiers to fully get the point across. The difference lies in the fact that 'to kill" is required to modify the meaning, but it is still grammatically correct without it. You need to explain what the cat likes to do though, otherwise that sentence is incomplete. So "to drink" can't be a modifier.
Why is it true that Poseidon is furious? Because his temple was desecrated. Here is a bit more, because I know the Poseidon example is a bit annoying:
Poseidon being furious is a state of mind, one that cannot necessarily be posed as fact. His emotion is speculative as a statement alone, therefore the author is offering the argument to prove Poseidon’s emotion. The author is positing the Poseidon must be furious because his temple was desecrated.
Economist: Countries with an uneducated population are destined to be weak economically and politically, whereas those with an educated population have governments that display a serious financial commitment to public education. So any nation with a government that has made such a commitment will avoid economic and political weakness.
Parsing out the Logic:
Clause #1: /Educated → Weak Econ&Pol
Contrapositive: /Weak Econ&Pol → Educated
Clause #2: Educated → Financial Commitment
Linked Clauses: /Weak Econ&Pol → Educated → Financial Commitment
Contrapositive: /Financial Commitment → /Educated → Weak Econ&Pol
Conclusion: Financial Commitment → /Weak Econ&Pol
As seen when parsing out the logic, and then subsequently linking the logic of the premise clauses, “financial commitment” is ultimately a necessary condition. The conclusion confuses the necessary condition of “financial commitment”, and calls it a sufficient condition. So we are looking for an answer choice that does the same thing.
Correct Answer Choice (B): People incapable of empathy are not good candidates for public office, but those who do have the capacity for empathy are able to manipulate others easily; hence, people who can manipulate others are good candidates for public office.
Parsing out the Logic:
Clause #1: /Empathy → /Good Candidates
Contrapositive: Good Candidates → Empathy
Clause #2: Empathy → Manipulative
Linked Clauses: Good Candidates → Empathy → Manipulative
Contrapositive: /Manipulative → /Empathy → /Good Candidates
Conclusion: Manipulative → Good Candidates
Answer Choice (B) makes the same mistake in that it confuses the necessary condition of being a “Good Candidate” for it being a sufficient condition.