User Avatar
Tutor
DeirdreWillgohs
Official Score
180

Deirdre graduated from Northwestern University with a degree in biomedical engineering and started her career in law as a patent examiner for the USPTO, later becoming a patent agent at a big law firm. During her time at Northwestern, she was a math and physics tutor for her fellow students and discovered her passion for teaching.

Deirdre believes the LSAT is a learnable test, and with the right approach and strategies, it can even be fun! She enjoys working with students of all levels, whether they want to work on their fundamentals at the beginning of their LSAT journey or refine their strategy to get those last few points to a 180.

When she isn’t teaching the LSAT, Deirdre enjoys fostering kittens and playing badminton.

deirdre.willgohs@7sage.com

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT102.S2.Q7
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Tuesday, Jun 3, 2025

Student Question:

This question stumped be a bit - I selected E because I labeled “this teaching is bound to mislead” as a subconclusion and the last sentence’s “individual spark...inevitable” as the main conclusion. This labeling led me to think that E both 1) restated the conclusion and 2) addressed the subconclusion as bonus.

After the video, it’s more clear to me that the last sentence is a premise. However, the incorrect answer choice E still feels plausible - how would you recommend I debunk this answer choice?

Tutor Response:

(E) is incorrect because it is referring to the last sentence of the stimulus, which supports "this teaching is bound to mislead." If a sentence or phrase is supporting another, then it cannot be the main conclusion. To see the relationship more clearly, try phrasing it in two possible ways:

1: This teaching is bound to mislead because the individual spark that happens to ignite a conflagration that was, in the prevailing conditions, inevitable.

or

2: The individual spark that happens to ignite a conflagration that was, in the prevailing conditions, inevitable because this teaching (that the assassination was the cause) is bound to mislead.

Which sentence makes more logical sense? You can see that in version 1, the "premise" clearly supports the conclusion, while in version 2, the "premise" does not provide any support or add any evidence to support the conclusion. This shows us that version 1 correctly illustrates the relationship between the two sentences, and thus (C) describes the main conclusion.

0
PrepTests ·
PT137.S1.P4.Q24
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Tuesday, Jun 3, 2025

Student Question:

For question 24, I came down to A and C. However, I eliminated A because A seemed like the context for the issues created by the absence of limitations, not the consequence of the absence of limitations. So why is the answer A?

Tutor Response:

First, I'd like to quickly go over the issues with (C). The passage doesn't support that it became increasingly easy for wealthy subjects to borrow money, just that it was easier for them than for the monarchs (see paragraph 4, lines 34-37). So (C) is unsupported.

Regarding correct answer choice (A), having difficulty financing the expansion of their empires was a direct consequence of monarchs having no limitations. If you take a look at paragraph 4, lines 28-35, you can see that it says that the monarchs earned a certain reputation as a consequence of not having limitations. This certain reputation made it more expensive (higher interest rates) for monarchs to borrow money. You can also find support for this in paragraph 3, lines 20-23. So with these citations in mind, we have established that monarchs at that time had difficulty borrowing money. Then, if you look at the beginning of paragraph 4, lines 24-26, you can see that the monarchs required lots of money to expand their empires. So we can see from all these excerpts from the text that monarchs therefore had a hard time financing the expansion of their empires.

1
PrepTests ·
PT121.S1.Q19
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

The reason I had a hard time choosing B is that even if biologists who do research fill a low number of administrative positions, the argument could still be that those that don’t do research fill an even lower number, so they could still be biased against biologists who don’t do research.

Tutor Response:

Keep in mind that this question is a Weaken question, so we are not trying to completely destroy the argument, but are simply making the conclusion less likely. This argument follows the general structure of noticing a phenomenon and concluding that there is a particular cause. One common way to weaken these kinds of arguments is to suggest another possible cause. (B) does this by implying that it is the focus on Biology that causes a bias, and not the lack of research. You are correct that that hypothetical scenario could be true, but the answer choice still makes the conclusion less likely.

4
PrepTests ·
PT158.S1.P2.Q9
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

Hello! Can you please elaborate on why the answer to question 9 would be B and not D? I ruled out B originally because they brought up a third category (raccoon), which I felt like was not similar to the passage where only two categories (trickster and picaro) are discussed. Thank you!

Tutor Response:

I see your line of reasoning! They do bring up a third category that doesn't really have an analog in the passage. I think it's possible that the analog could be considered an "agent of satire," but that doesn't feel clear to me. What I noticed most about (B) was the mention of superficial similarities, which seemed central to the issue of comparing the picaro and the trickster. (D) doesn't explain why the miscategorization occurs, and it actually seems to show superficial differences, rather than similarities. That's what was most salient to me about (D) and why I would lean toward (B).

6
PrepTests ·
PT121.S1.Q16
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

I don’t see how D would justify the reasoning. The conclusion is that the approach should be changed, and D says that abstract frameworks are most appropriate. However, it doesn’t say that this means that approaches should be changed to an abstract framework. There could still be reasons for not changing the current approach. However, I know that D is the only answer choice that even touches on the conclusion by mentioning abstract frameworks.

Tutor Response:

For this question, I think it's important to remember that we are simply trying to strengthen the conclusion, not completely guarantee it. So even though there could be scenarios where (D) doesn't guarantee the conclusion, it still strengthens the argument by strengthening the connect between abstract ethical theory and specific principles, like you noted.

0
PrepTests ·
PT126.S4.Q20
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

On this question, I initially picked B but then on my blind review I thought B weakened the argument instead of strengthening. It says trial by jury is not fair... answer B states the juror will be in favor therefore it would not be fair, I found this strengthened the conclusion rather than weakening it? I decided to go with D because it added new information as to a possibility that an expert gives the trial a fair means because it will explain what the juror has no knowledge of

Tutor Response:

I think there was maybe some confusion about what the conclusion is in this question. The conclusion is that in their current state, jury trials are not fair. In their current state, jury trials exclude experts. If (B) were true, the exclusion of experts helps ensure fairness by excluded some people who are biased, which goes against the conclusion. (D) is an interesting choice but experts who provide testimony (aka expert witnesses) are not on the juries; they are instead called as witnesses. So any fairness on the part of an expert witness/expert providing testimony has no bearing on the fairness of experts serving on the jury.

1
PrepTests ·
PT108.S1.P1.Q2
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

How would you be able to pick B? D was really compelling. I understand why JY pointed it out to be wrong, but how is B any better? I’m having a hard time picking that up.

Tutor Response:

Answer choice (B) is a good choice because we are explicitly told that Kahlo's work has been exhaustively psychoanalyzed, and are told that political analysis has been lacking (first paragraph). In the next sentence, we are told that Kahlo was a political activist who through her art sought to explore her own roots (making psychoanalysis relevant to her work) and also championed Mexico's struggle for an independent political and cultural identity (making political analysis relevant to her work). So, because her work has these two goals (herself and politics) the two methods of analyzing her work would complement one another to get the full picture.

-3
PrepTests ·
PT110.S3.Q20
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

What I don’t understand about why the correct answer is A is how the fact that both metaphors are pervasive to the same extent undermines the argument? Why can’t those two peacefully coexist where a metaphor “society as a body” supports authoritartian regime and the family one is about something else? The fact that political utility determines the popularity of a metaphor also doesn’t contradict cause it doesn’t say that it determines what’s gonna be THE MOST popular. They both can be as popular.

Tutor Response:

The conclusion in this argument is that the "society as a body" metaphor "promotes greater acceptance of authoritarian repression than do other metaphors." The evidence supporting this is "political utility determines the popularity of a metaphor" and "in authoritarian societies, the metaphor of society as a human body governed by a head is pervasive." These pieces of evidence, or premises, are fact. In an authoritarian society, a metaphor about something else would not be politically useful. Authoritarian societies would not want to promote another type of society. This means that if something else is just as popular, it must be just as politically useful for authoritarian societies, which goes against our conclusion.

0
PrepTests ·
PT110.S4.P2.Q12
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

Why (E) is wrong? I interpreted as the drama ‘includes’ or ‘contain’ the ‘concept’ of freedom that is most familiar to the modern Western world. Could you please provide further explanation?

Tutor Response:

Your interpretation of "embodies" is fine, but the issue with (E) is that we have no idea what notion of freedom is most familiar to the modern Western World. That requires a large assumption on our part as to what that notion really is, and the text does not give us any indication of what that notion is. Thus, (E) is unsupported by the text.

0
PrepTests ·
PT155.S4.Q19
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

Around 4:50, JY says Chapman would disagree and some is not an equivalent to “many.” How do we know this? How do we know its not an equivalent of many if many can mean 1 or more. Does many mean at some which means at least 1? If its ambigious how do we know which to prefer? Because some “at least 1” as JY pointed out would change this to an agree stance where both speakers agree.

Tutor Response:

This is interesting. I would say that if we change "only one" to "some" then that is no longer saying the same thing. Colloquially, "many" implies a larger number than "some," and that may be what JY is getting at in this video. I would by default assume that "many" and "some" are interchangeable in the LSAT and only differentiate between the two if it is the last possible answer choice remaining (ie picking the best of the worst). Keep in mind that the answer choice does say "only one" and not some, so this ambiguity isn't present in the answer choice.

1
PrepTests ·
PT137.S3.Q4
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, Jun 2, 2025

Student Question:

Could you explain why C is wrong?

Tutor Response:

(C) is not the best choice because it is not the answer that most weakens the conclusion. (C) and correct answer (B) both make the study an imperfect study, which weakens the conclusions we can draw from it, but (B) weakens the study in a much worse way than (C). (C) simply means that the study wasn't done blind, which is actually unavoidable in some real-life studies as well and doesn't necessarily make the results useless. (B) however is an imbalance in the groups being tested and makes the results useless because it is now impossible to know how much the results were due to the different scents and how much the results were due to the difference in the groups. That's why (C) isn't the best answer here.

1
PrepTests ·
PT101.S4.P2.Q11
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Saturday, May 31, 2025

Student Question:

I understand why the answer choice is correct. My issue is with finding the answer within the text. I searched everywhere and could not find it, so I just guessed for my answer. Thanks :)

Tutor Response:

If you take a look at the bottom of the first paragraph, the following provides support for the correct answer choice: "Indeed, in most cases involving ancient graves, to recognize that Native Americans have standing would represent a significant expansion of common law." If something would be a significant expansion of common law, that means that it is not currently true within common law.

0
PrepTests ·
PT108.S3.Q16
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Saturday, May 31, 2025

Student Question:

if this is the set up: If act responsibly → act on basis of info that one has made reasonable effort to make sure is accurate and complete

why can’t the answer be B?

Tutor Response:

Thanks for your question. The issue with (B) is that we can't prove we have met the sufficient condition just by meeting the necessary conditions. If we assume that Mary's actions mean that she met the condition of "act[ing] on the basis of information that one has made a reasonable effort to make sure is accurate and complete" we still don't know if that is sufficient to say she was acting responsibly. We know we have met a necessary component, but what if it's never responsible to fire people? We don't know the sufficient conditions for being responsible. ​

To see the difference between sufficient and necessary, let's take a look at the following: to get good grades, you must read the textbook.

good grades -> read the textbook

But is reading the textbook sufficient to get good grades? Not that we've shown yet, no. Maybe if you read the textbook and show up to all the tests you'll get good grades, or maybe if you also bribe the teacher you'll get good grades. We don't know. All we know is that reading the textbook is a necessary component to getting good grades, but we don't know that it gets us all the way there.

0
PrepTests ·
PT102.S3.Q18
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Saturday, May 31, 2025

Student Question:

I chose option D; I do not understand how option E would be correct / how do we know that the total amount of spending went down?

Tutor Response:

This is a sufficient assumption question, so the correct answer will be something that, if assumed, is sufficient to allow us to arrive at the conclusion. If we assume the total spending went down like in (E), and we already know a smaller percentage of money is being spent on effective treatments, then this lets us conclude that less money is being spent on effective treatments (a smaller percentage of a smaller total = smaller amount).

0
PrepTests ·
PT102.S2.Q12
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Saturday, May 31, 2025

Student Question:

I chose D and when doing my wrong answer journal I realize I chose it because it says “[there are no] known anthracosaur fossils that predate some lizard fossils,” which in the context of the question seems to be necessary for our hypothesis. Is it the fact that is uses known vs unknown that makes it incorrect or is that the term “some lizard fossils” is too weak to encapsulate the need for something strong like “any/all lizard fossils”

I do understand why A is correct because it is strong in saying “no unknown anthra fossils older than 340,” but curious if “no known anthra fossils older than 340” would be valid too?

Tutor Response:

The issue with (D) is that it says "some" lizard fossils. Lizards could have lived at the same time as or continue to exist after anthracosaurs (and they do!) but that doesn't mean they didn't also come before anthracosaurs. So the negation of (D) doesn't ruin the argument.

Regarding your question about choice (A), you're correct that we also need there to be no known anthra fossils older than 340!

4
PrepTests ·
PT152.S3.P4.Q23
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Friday, May 30, 2025

Student Question:

For Q 23, JY said there is a difference between reconciling the fourth paragraph (Paragraph 5) and supporting the fourth paragraph (Paragraph 3). However, I am still confused about why if P5 reconciles P4, it doesn’t support P4. Thanks.

Tutor Response:

This is definitely a very tricky question. With paragraph 3, there is very strong support for why they even think there would be a cold empty starting point-- because the alternative is unlikely based on the 2nd law of thermodynamics (3rd paragraph). Paragraph 5 doesn't explain why they would think there would be a cold, empty starting point, just that it is possible. This doesn't very strongly support the idea, it just means it's not completely out of the running. But something being possible doesn't support it actually being the case, we need something stronger to actually say it is likely the case, which the 3rd paragraph does. You could interpret paragraph 5 as providing mild support, but paragraph 3 contains much stronger support.

1
PrepTests ·
PT142.S2.Q22
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Friday, May 30, 2025

Student Question:

Hi - I think the answer here is pretty straightforward, but I don’t agree with the thinking that the tutor here is pursuing. He is saying that the prediction implies a hypothesis that Spending isn’t casually related to Anxiety/Depression. But isn’t there a possibility that it actually is, but when it’s too much it has negative affects. Essentially, there is a “sweet spot” in the middle, which would explain a “U” shaped graph between leisure spending and anxiety/depression. I am not saying that is the relationship, but what I am saying is that you can’t infer with certainty that there is NO causation here. Let me know if that makes sense.

Tutor Answer:

I think I understand what you're saying! I definitely see the "U" shaped correlation being a possibility with the original stimulus, but I think answer (C) doesn't imply that-- it implies a different shape, a simple line \ that tracks increased spending with decreased anxiety/depression. Either way, it would still possibly weaken the conclusion, because now we might associate increased spending with decreased anxiety and not want to decrease spending (if we assume these older adults provide results applicable to the first years). The longer I look at this answer choice, the more I feel it is neutral.

0
PrepTests ·
PT125.S2.Q26
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Friday, May 30, 2025

Student Question:

Why is answer choice A a bad option, D does not make sense as the best option

Tutor Answer:

The conclusion is that if the newspaper is correct regarding "new sirens -> public safety enhanced" then the public safety will be enhanced next year. But that's assuming that the sufficient condition (new sirens) was triggered. We need to find an assumption that triggers the sufficient for our correct answer, and (D) does that. We already know that a local company selling replacement parts went out of business, but maybe there is a second local company that sells them, or maybe ordering them online is easy, or something else along those lines. (D) proves that it really will be difficult to obtain parts, and therefore new sirens will be purchased, which allows the conclusion to follow.

(A) doesn't really get us to our conclusion. Even if new sirens were the only way to increase public safety, we still haven't proven that new sirens actually will be installed. Have you tried diagramming out this problem to see how all the premises work together? I find diagrams extremely helpful for sufficient assumptions!

0
PrepTests ·
PT140.S3.Q23
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Thursday, May 29, 2025

Student Question:

Hi! I have a question about E.Even tho i got this one correct, i’m having trouble with the word “doctors”is this one right because1) just saying “doctors” could mean either all of them or some of them if no distinction is providedOR2) it is MSS question?

Tutor Answer:

This is a really good question. I think in regards to (1), it depends on context. If this were conditional reasoning, I would say "doctors" means all doctors, no exceptions. In causal reasoning, I would take "doctors" to mean doctors in general, so most, but there could be some exceptions. Because this is MSS, I would feel comfortable with the term "doctors" because even though I don't have definitive proof it is all doctors, we said as a premise that doctors are encouraged to be rude, and I can assume that we mean "doctors" in the same sense as the premise. If this were a Must Be True question, I would not feel as comfortable with (E).

1
PrepTests ·
PT129.S3.Q25
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Thursday, May 29, 2025

Student Question:I want to ask why E is correct. I understand how it works, and I was about to choose it until I thought about it more. We don’t know anything about the preferences of the manager’s employees, and that made me go with B.

Tutor Response:

I agree that don't know definitively what the preferences of those employees are, but it's a decent argument to say that those employees would have a similar preference as the other company's employees. It's making a conclusion about two analogous things: one company's employees and another company's employees. (B) isn't very well supported because there isn't an indication that familiarity is more important-- it could be that what is more important is just picking something the employees will actually use.

1
PrepTests ·
PT145.S4.Q20
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Thursday, May 29, 2025

Student Question:

I am just a bit turned upside down since JY is sort of running through the explanations, and I feel that he relies on his intuitions and doesn't sufficiently explain his logic. I am struggling to see the gap. From the explanation, it sounds like that this is a biconditional that does not appear as such. Is this how it is presenting? I am also simply just struggling with finding the gap here (if you could please help me through this → or if you have a tried and true phrase to find a gap, please share).

Tutor Answer:

The way I would map this conclusion out for myself is in two versions as follows:

1) Selena not lying (has powers) -> possible to have powers

2) Selena lying (doesn't have powers) -> not possible to have powers

The reason I feel comfortable doing that is because the conclusion is if we find out whether her claim is true then we find out whether it is possible to have powers. This means our conclusion has to work in the scenario where she isn't lying and work in the scenario where she is lying.

Version 1 of the conclusion makes intuitive sense, I think-- if she has powers then it must be possible to have powers. But version 2 is where we need to start making assumptions. Why does her not having powers mean no one else can have powers? We need to assume that must be the case for some reason, otherwise the conclusion doesn't make sense anymore. That's the gap we're looking to fill.

In general, for Sufficient Assumption I find it extremely helpful to diagram out the conclusion and the premises. It helps me keep track of all the information and visually see what is missing from the premises yet is present in the conclusion. It doesn't work for every single question, but it works for most!

1
PrepTests ·
PT156.S4.Q21
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Tuesday, May 27, 2025

Student Question:

Why is bi-conditionality assumed for this argument where the conditions are both sufficient and necessary in order to be eligible? Specifically, why does the second sentence set out this bi-conditionality?

Tutor Answer:

I wouldn't really say there's anything about the second sentence that indicates a biconditional, but rather the fact that the stimulus is labeled "company policy." It would be odd if there were another relevant policy that they just failed to mention. Additionally, none of the answer choices make sense unless we assume biconditionality, so as soon as I see that I'm going to assume we can be a little lax with our interpretation of the conditional direction.

0
PrepTests ·
PT153.S2.Q23
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Tuesday, May 27, 2025

Student Question:

I chose A instead of B because I thought it was too much of an inference to assume that being less physically fit (in the premise of B) is an example of “children can incur health risks”. They may be less fit, but have strong immune systems that would render them safe from health risks. JY doesn’t seem to touch on that “flaw”, so I want to ask, is that a reasonable assumption to make? Are we purely just looking at pattern (since this is a pattern of reasoning) and not the discrepancies within the pattern? Thanks!

Tutor Answer:

That's a very interesting train of thought, but I could just as easily apply it to the stimulus too: we assume that the public does not have enough training in statistics to avoid being misinformed, or that there isn't another person correcting the misinformation, or that the instance where the journalist "erroneously reported that a certain candidate would win an election" actually misinformed the public. So I would say it's reasonable to make this type of assumption as we also need it for the stimulus!

1
PrepTests ·
PT110.S1.P2.Q12
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, May 26, 2025

Student Question:

For question 12, the answer says the third species is similar to the two but isn’t it the root of them?

Tutor Answer:

I see what you mean, but I think that to say the third is the root is too definitive. At most, we can tell from lines 30-33 that the two musical forms could be linked to this older religious tradition, but we don't know for sure that the tradition is the root of both. Something could be related to another, older thing, but not necessarily deriving from it.

0
PrepTests ·
PT133.S1.Q19
User Avatar
DeirdreWillgohs
Monday, May 26, 2025

Student Question:

I’m confused by the explanation for why E is incorrect. I went into the question thinking that the correct answer would be “If the DNA is different then they did not interbreed.” Or the contrapositive “If they had interbred, the DNA would be the same.” Answer Choice E felt to me to be a sufficient-necessary problem that instead said “If the DNA is the same, then they interbred.” Since the explanations do not address that, I just wanted to ask if that is correct or not. The video mentioned causal relationships and being too strong, but I hadn’t been thinking that far.

Tutor Answer:

I think your initial thought was definitely on the right track, and I agree with your take on the sufficient-necessary issue! Translating (E) using "must" as our indicator, we would get "if there are any similarities in the DNA, they interbred," which is the wrong order. The rest of the explanations for (E) also work, but it's fine to rule things out for different reasons.

1

Confirm action

Are you sure?