@nbarchaim It would not be. We only know one rule of the classroom. That if you were cited as late, then you were 5+ minutes late. Since we only know Kumar was 17 minutes late, we can't make any inferences about how he was cited. Maybe he always shows up 17 minutes late, so the teacher doesn't mark him down. Maybe Kumar is a TA and can't be cited as late. There is no way to make a valid conclusion that he was cited as late.

Hi! I'm in Detroit and currently studying for the January LSAT. I'd be interested in forming a group