User Avatar
JumpyPilot
Joined
Dec 2024
Subscription
Free

Admissions profile

LSAT
178
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
Not provided

Applications

Columbia
In process
Duke
In process
Yale
In process

Discussions

User Avatar

Monday, Dec 29, 2025

JumpyPilot

PT159.S4.P3.Q18

I'm not understanding why D is the correct answer choice for this question, help is appreciated!

My thinking:

Given that the author states that the Maya have to rely on other countries' precedents because "courts in Belize have not yet ruled on... indigenous rights" and that there is an "absence of relevant precedent in Belize's case law" I don't know how the author's purpose can then be to suggest that "the courts of Belize have relied upon the sorts of common law precedents that the Maya argue should be applied."

In my head, it is inconsistent to suggest that there is both an absence of "relevant" precedent in Belize law (meaning nothing even close can be applied) and to suggest that Belize courts have "relied... upon the sorts of... precedent the Maya argue should be applied."

Where am I messing up? Thanks!

1

Confirm action

Are you sure?