Mikey is from the Bay Area and has only recently learned to shut up about that. He studied philosophy at Yale, then went to Yale again for law school. There he discovered a deep, residing passion for not being a lawyer.
After law school, he went home and founded a tutoring company where every hour purchased was matched one-for-one with an hour given pro bono to low income students in Oakland. He did that for 10 amazing years, and he always insisted his LSAT students use 7sage – the company with the best curriculum and the best ethics (it’s not even close).
Now he’s living the dream – making content with J.Y. and Kevin, and helping to refine the curriculum he has admired from afar for over a decade.
He’s a father, a trad climber, a hockey player, and an avidly goofy goose.
Applications
Discussions
@hh29800 It's a relevant consideration when you're evaluating the argument's overall strength, but the core "people can be wrong about things" concept applies no matter how much expertise you pile on.
@JP_ To your first reply, the obvious (and completely unhelpful) answer is to interpret language precisely the first time around. That can kinda improve with dedicated practice, but the reality is we all misread things sometimes.
The more important thing is to suspect yourself of having misread something when none of the answer choices seem right. You say you'd have done better if you scrutinized those words, so the point of focus is to make "go back and scrutinize key words" a more prominent part of your process.
To your second reply, yep that's right.
@jaredimranahmed849 Everyone being pleased and satisfied is what enables (D)'s normative language.
@CaitlynL We aren't talking about crafting individual HCPs in a specific way. Like "there's a right way and a wrong way to make an HCP".
Instead we are indeed discussing the law on which all these HCPs are based -- that's what allows for this pragmatic compromise to occur.
@JP_ I get the semantic distinction you're making between belief and opinion -- the two concepts do have different meanings on their face. Like maybe opinions are more subjective?
But in this case, where we're talking about her opinion about a matter of fact, the distinction is untenable.
Consider the following scenario:
Shayna believes Daniel would prefer kindness to honesty.
Shayna is asked "Do you think Daniel prefers kindness to honesty?"
Shayna says "I have no opinion."
Shayna's comment would be disingenuous here. She does have an opinion/belief: she thinks he prefers kindness to honesty.
Perhaps you think "opinion" isn't the best choice of words because "opinion "really does just mean "belief" here, but there's no world where she has no opinion and also a secret belief.
@suhyahn Correlational claims can be validly inverted.
Basic formal logic systems like first order and set logic don't have the capacity to represent correlational claims. "Few Unfulfilled Desires --> Happy" would be a subpar translation, for example.
Correlational claims say "as you move this slider up, this other slider moves up too". It follows that as you move the slider back down, the other slider will move back down as well.
@Haleh They're interpreting "fast service" to mean "the food is served quickly", which imo is a reasonable interpretation. Fast service has a downside, just like honesty has a downside.
LR in Action? Flaw Factory? Flippyhouse Fondue?
I'm gonna start teaching some more straightforward classes instead of the niche hipster stuff I've been doing. What classes should I teach?
@Hallurx8 yeah the category is "flaw or descriptive weakening" because of questions like this one, which essentially are weaken questions.
@MilaTrubint This one's pretty unique tbh, but you can filter by the LR Stimulus Logic tag "Math" for more questions in its general vicinity.
@ert I think you laid out the logic well. The link between wealth and cancer is much weaker and less direct than the link between pollution and cancer. These questions are inherently comparative, leaning on real-world intuitions about the relationships between concepts. The difference between (B) and (D) is an excellent example of this, and quite typical.
@AshleyThomas It was a great question! And no shade for needing to vent after getting smacked by this problem lol. It's bonkers.
@Nia [ignores the possibility that] --> what if...
[those who participate both in the lunch program and in extracurricular activities] --> the group of double-program kids
[do not include both urban and rural students] --> is 100% urban or 100% rural
What if the group of double-program kids is 100% urban or 100% rural?
@AshleyThomas the ability to parse dense analogies is absolutely crucial to legal argumentation. of all the skillsets the LSAT tests, tracking analogies is arguably the most relevant
@JamesLong this sounds like an issue for our student services team, whom you can message directly when you encounter a suspected bug. gonna just tag @AgnesAlojado in for convenience
@AlexHaro Yeah "will surely" signals certainty. Like if something is a "sure thing", or "for sure", or "I'm sure".
@guzsarah Feedback always welcome! Especially critical feedback. And yeah these long ones were part of an early experiment I've since dialed way back on, so your take is the popular one I think.
@rrhj1986 The application is the inverse, not the contrapositive. If the principle is A --> B, the application is notA --> notB.
@1473874885 Here’s an explanation for why applying the inverse of a rule isn't valid logic.
@leahsingleton201698 For my answer to this question, see (E)'s explanation. If anyone has follow-up questions, @me.
@gonewiththewind Coherentsolutionsfortheproblemofreducinghealthcarecostscannotbefoundwithinthecurrentpiecemealsystemofpayingthesecosts.Thereasonisthatthissystemgiveshealthcareprovidersandinsurerseveryincentivetoshift,whereverpossible,thecostsoftreatingillnessontoeachotheroranyotherparty,includingthepatient.Thatclearlyisthelessonofthevariousreformsofthe1980s:pushinononepartofthispliablespendingballoonandanequallyexpensivebulgepopsupelsewhere.Forexample,whenthegovernmenthealthcareinsuranceprogramforthepoorcutcostsbydisallowingpaymentsforsomevisitstophysicians,patientswithadvancedillnesslaterpresentedthemselvesathospitalemergencyroomsinincreasednumbers.