- Joined
- Dec 2025
- Subscription
- Core
Admissions profile
Discussions
Although I got this Question wrong under timed conditions, after spending an inordinate amount of time in review- It finally Clicked.
The key to understanding this question is honing on the conclusion as it exists.
C may seem innocuous as weakener if one is trying to weaken the idea of greatly increased risk to US consumers; It, nonetheless, perfectly weakens the conclusion if one reads the conclusion for what it is- "THIS PRACTICE greatly increases the health risk to US consumers"
Which Practice? The practice of exporting banned pesticides.
Why? Because These pesticides, that are being exported, are applied to agri products that are imported into the country.
Well What IF there are other countries that are also supplying the banned pesticides which are sprayed on the products?
Then This practice of exporting banned pesticides couldn't possibly be greatly increasing the health risks, because the producer of agri products is sourcing the banned pesticides from elsewhere anyway.
Thanks! Although, I got this right, I didn't think about it in terms of making the the two more analogous. Very Helpful.
This, Unlike some of the other criticisms, is actually valid. I 100% agree with you that a "Musical Arranger" is not something most people know.
I would like to add something, that I feel other explanations are lacking:
The question is not about Lowe's Study or Conclusions, instead it is about the Method used to build the chronology and arrive at a hypothesis.
The method in question being one which utilises archaeological record and certain assumptions to build a hypothesis that accommodates the evidence.
This method Generally Accpeted as is evidenced y this line:
Like previous investigators, Lowe relies on dated monuments to construct a step-by-step account of the actual collapse.
and it is Questionable as shown through the following:
If there is a central flaw in Lowe's explanation, it is that the entire edifice rests on the assumption that the available evidence paints a true picture of how the collapse proceeded. However, it is difficult to know how accurately the archaeological record reflects historic activity, especially of a complex civilization such as the Mayans', and a hypothesis can be tested only against the best available data. It is quite possible that our understanding of the collapse might be radically altered by better data.
Indicating, the reliance of the entire hypothesis on a key assumption.
It is important to remember that the question is about the Author's stance on the Method.
Waiting lists increasing for Community gardens, as opposed to private gardens, shows that maybe the demand for and increase in sales of seeds can be explained by it. Thus, weakening the causal conclusion.
I would love to hear anyone who can help me understand why that is not the case.
@emmarita This was my rational too! in the video explanations though they have conveniently misread community as personal and thus dismissed the option. Would have liked a proper reason for C.
I chose D:
If an insecticide can effectively control pest populations as well as predator populations, then it should be used instead of predators to control pest populations.
Because, of the first line of the passage:
Sometimes there is no more effective means of controlling an agricultural pest than giving free rein to its natural predators.
"Sometimes" implying that normally there might be other ways of handling the situation, such as the alternative- Insecticides.
Although, I did not love picking it, it felt like the least bad option out of the rest.
That being said, in review, I realised the contra-positive of C makes more sense. Here it is:
If the use of natural predators has not proven Inadequate, Then Insecticides should not be used to control certain pest populations.
In the passage, the new Sufficient Condition has been met and ,in fact, proven to be adequate:
Throughout the study, populations of cyclamen mites remained low in plots shared with Typhlodromus, but their infestation attained significantly damaging proportions on predator-free plants.
and
A case in point is the cyclamen mite, a pest whose population can be effectively controlled by a predatory mite of the genus Typhlodromus.
another day, another utterly stupid question. In no world does quoting someone else make the speaker a supporter of the quoted claim, but apparently here it does.
Some people believe insider trading isn't entirely wrong because whatever. But I don't and here is an entire passage explaining my stance. But, Sure, feel free to believe that I,in fact, implied that insider trading has some benefits.
B is wrong for Two reasons. The first, as stated in the AC explanation, is the reversed chain of logic. The other one, according to me, is that the Stimulus talks about "Client's Profits" whereas AC B talks about "Company Profits" .
@allegralg I beg to differ. Effusiveness refers to a strong expression of emotion- this could be for one's victory or towards the opponents loss. Point being, the coach does not have to say what the object of the effusive response is- it is safe to assume either.
I wrote this analogy to explain the prompt. Open to criticism.
Picture This- My Preferred car manufacturer used to produce an SUV X which did had medium sized tires, but now they produce SUV Y which has Huge tiers. Therefore, the new model, Y, should not be considered an SUV.
Here, it is apparent that the speaker is assuming that the tire size is a defining feature of an SUV. Which we know to be false and thus, find easier to challenge.
In this Analogy, C would be saying- Yeah but they were produced by the same Manufacturer so they should be considered SUVs.
E on the other hand calls out the assumption and states that there are more elements that define an SUV and that Y shares to elements more with X than any other model.
Let me know if this helps.
@markymymarkymark768 This was my exact thought, including affirming, at best, the possibility of satisfying the necessary condition. Of course, the false equivalence of the two statements is a neat trick!
Sorry, but A requires us to assume that the vague language of AC A, as it relates to time periods, refers to the the very edges, i.e. 60s referring to late or very late 60s and 70s referring to 70 or very early 70s.
If those assumptions are not made then how do you explain the causality? I swear I can think of ACs that were incorrect because they required such assumptions.
If interpreted as one would normally, it would look something like this : number of deer living in NA increased dramatically around '65 while pesticides were banned around '75. So? How are these things related?
Highly Inconsistent on the part of LSAT.
138.1.11, Chose E.
Reference:
Still other secondary substances are not in themselves harmful to insects, but are characteristic smells or tastes that dissuade the insect from feeding by warning it of the presence of some other substance that is harmful.
From the above statement we can only infer the presence of such toxic chemicals that coexist with the secondary substances. Option E falters when it goes beyond this inference and concludes that said toxic substances "evolved in correlation" with secondary substances.
Based on my understanding of the passage, we are not informed on how, when or why this particular toxic substance + secondary substance combination came to be. We just know that it exists.
For this reason the conclusion in Option E is unsupported by the Passage.
Someone Help me understand this please:
Claim: way to to remedy crime --> Increasing the number of police officers
Stat: Major cities have similar ratios of Police officers to Citizens, yet some have a high rate of crime while others have a low rate.
Meaning: despite the number of police officers there does not seem to be a correlation between Police per capita and Crime rate.
Question: Isn't this the perfect weakener to a causation argument? By showing that there is in fact no correlation between the variables.
A causes B
if we show that A and B are not correlated that would weaken the argument.
Doubt: How is A not the correct answer?
I can see how E is the better answer choice because how easy it is to support as a claim, but why not A?