User Avatar
RoadRunner
Joined
Apr 2025
Subscription
Free

Admissions profile

LSAT
Not provided
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
Not provided

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT147.S3.P4.Q26
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Saturday, Nov 2, 2024

26 - I struggle with why D is correct and why B (my choice) is wrong.

For D, author B never says that he/she believes that high earners pay less under a flat tax. Author B makes an if - then argument, but never states the belief that the "if" is satisfied. Thus, we don't know that there is factual disagreement about that fact.

For answer B, author A seems to accept the notion (argued by proponents of progressive taxes) that high-earners pay a greater share of their earnings in taxes under a progressive system. But author B has this whole point about the individual not being taxed differently, just different dollar amounts. I hear author B saying, "high-earners as individuals do not pay more under progressive taxes. Their first xyz $ are taxed the same as low earners, and it's only their earnings in excess of xyz$ that they pay at a higher rate.". I personally don't find this persuasive, but it's what author B seems to believe. It seems that he/she would disagree with the statement that high earners pay more under a progressive system.

1
PrepTests ·
PT147.S3.P3.Q16
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Saturday, Nov 2, 2024

16 - I don't understand how C is unambiguously the right answer. The behavior in C would be unethical under theoretical equipoise, but not under clinical equipoise. The passage describes theoretical equipoise as a fact that exists in the real world. The author has not yet won the battle of converting everyone to clinical equipoise. So how is C not unethical at the time the article was penned?

4
PrepTests ·
PT152.S1.Q1
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Saturday, Sep 14, 2024

I made the exact same mistake for the exact same reason, and it still "bothers" me. I found A and E equally helpful in strengthening the argument. A tells us that swallowing whole leaves isn't just part of their normal diet, which is the most obvious competing explanation for why they would do this. A rules that out and confirms that it is unusual for them to do this. So while it doesn't strengthen the link to the actual explanation, it rules out a wide range of other explanations.

1
PrepTests ·
PT120.S4.Q11
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Tuesday, Aug 27, 2024

Ah - super helpful. (1) definitely fighting the test here (thanks for giving me the label for that emotion!) and (2) If I (properly) read the prompt as "Some Historian is saying X to advance some kind of argument" rather than "LSAT writers are making truth claim Y", I can see where I took a wrong turn. Thanks again for your replies!

1
PrepTests ·
PT120.S4.Q11
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Tuesday, Aug 27, 2024

Thanks for your quick reply! I see that E is the most natural (fewest additional assumptions) answer if prompts can include false claims. I guess I just wasn't ready for that possibility. If, by contrast, you assume that prompts must not include false claims, then my argument is sort of a logical necessity - it's the only way I can think of, of reconciling the prompt's different statements as all true. It's constructed, but also necessary to be able to take each statement in the prompt as true. In that sense, to me, it follows logically, rather than being an external assumption. And then, B follows better than E, in my view. Answer E sort of seems to me like saying "If claim A in the prompt is true, then claim B in the prompt is false". I wasn't ready for prompts nesting claims that we can view as "not true". But I see how that's a fallacy on my part - we are asked to determine what follows logically from the prompt, and it says nowhere that that conclusion cannot contradict part of the prompt, as long as it follows logically. Still, it feels like a prompt that says "A = 5, and A = 7", with the correct answer choice being "if A not equal 5, then A = 7". I was trying too hard to find a way for A to equal both 5 and 7...

0
PrepTests ·
PT120.S4.Q11
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Tuesday, Aug 27, 2024

But the two statements can be reconciled if we grant that children of traditional parents who do not misbehave emerge more self-confidently from the differential treatment. This reading has the advantage of being able to take the entire prompt as true - there is no contradiction. So it may feel like we're making an additional assumption, but it is one that allows us to take the entire prompt as "true", which I thought was the basis for these inference questions. If we have to litigate which claims by two different groups in the same prompt is correct and who is wrong, it seems like all bets are off anyways! And under that reading, answer B looks really good - if traditional parenting makes "good children" more confident and "bad children" less confident, we would expect a wider dispersion of confidence in traditionally parented children, without necessarily changing the average.

0
PrepTests ·
PT149.S2.P3.Q17
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Friday, Jul 19, 2024

on Q17:

E) Where does it say in passage B that a chef who observes the social norms of his profession obtains a professional benefit from doing so? All it says is that the chefs with whom the recipe originated, benefit from other chefs observing the norms. The answer is implied perhaps, but not stated as clearly as in passage A, which says that comedians who violate the norms of their profession are ostracized (hence, observing them is a benefit).

B) I don't understand why this is not the better answer. The social norms among comedians provide the equivalent of one form of intellectual property protection (copyright), while the social norms among chefs establish three of them: patent, trade secrecy, and copyright. Isn't that precisely more elaborate than what comedians have to work with?

1
PrepTests ·
PT122.S1.Q16
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Thursday, Jul 4, 2024

I don't understand why D is not the best answer. It strikes me as an alternative explanation for the increase in prices. Rather than the "thin-ness" of supply, it is the fact that another buyer (government producers) enters the market when there are production shortfalls, increasing demand. Taking this as true, we no longer need to blame the increase in prices on the small size of the market, thus weakening the analyst's rationale. To see the difference, note that D would also explain the rise in prices when governments do NOT control so much of the rice market. That's why it weakens the analyst's rationale so well.

0
PrepTests ·
PT154.S1.Q16
User Avatar
RoadRunner
Sunday, Jun 9, 2024

So the discussion of C seems to assume that the chroniclers did in fact write about merchants or nobles at all. But the words don't say that. The words say "clergy very rarely displayed merchants and nobles as religious". That could be because (1) they did not write about them at all or (2) because they wrote about them but did not describe them as religious when they wrote about them. But the words here don't give us the right to assume (2), and if it's (1) then C does not provide the strong counterexample that - in the discussion - made it the right answer. It's entirely possible (working only with what the prompt and answer choice give us) that the clergy only ever wrote about peasants.

0

Confirm action

Are you sure?