I chose E, am I cooked?

"If Pollution is a Problem" and "If Pollution exists" are NOT the same ideas, how are you overlooking this?

There is another obvious reason to eliminate E

The principle says in the necessary conditions that one must "HOPE OR EXPECT...benefit..." if one should criticize.

Answer choice E is only concerned with EXPECTING benefit but one can still HOPE for something while NOT EXPECTING. Answer choice E doesn't rule out the possibility that Jarrett could still hope to benefit someone w/o expecting to benefit someone.

@cwferrari "I went off vibes, it's E" nice