- Joined
- May 2026
- Subscription
- Free
Admissions profile
Discussions
True, you'd definetly have to have some strong intuition and logic to apply multiplayer layers to refute the flaw in a flawed statement about a flawed argument like this.
On the LSAT, we're trained to not assume that lack of evidence = evidence of falseness. Why are we meant to assume that because wine made with grapes may be more likely to reduce the risk of premature heart disease than other wines, the latter must be UNLIKELY to reduce the risk of premature heart disease at all? This is balls.
@rawasson yeah how else are we going to keep the working class oppressed and obedient to authority
I picked C, and was quite upset for a while, because I believed C and E were pretty much the same, save for an arbitrary difference in the interpretation of "it must not be a good idea."
However, I realized that C proposes that the argument presumes that unionizing must not be a good idea precisely because most of the students are unaware of it. As in, the students not being aware of the unionization attempt alone must mean it shouldn't happen.
However, the argument doesn't do this. It presumes that the students explicitly disapprove of unionization because of both the majority of the students' lack of awareness, or lack of approval for it. The argument explicitly assumes that the students disapprove of it, and uses that as its reasoning, instead of using lack of awareness on its own as the reason against the unionization effort.
A's explanation implies that the 50%+ of the journalism students that came from jobs in journalism KEPT their jobs through their education, which I don't think is a necessary condition. I believed that they left their jobs to pursue education, then got new jobs afterwards. Therefore, my reasoning didn't align with the LSAT god's reasoning. Is this arbitrary? Can someone help?
Weaken questions' correct answer may use a disconnect in one condition of the answer with the argument (nanobes aren't necessarily single-celled organisms) to distract from the subtler condition that undermines the answer (life can reproduce and exist without their own reproductive mechanism, thus so can nanobes). Weaken answers depend on an intermediary, rather than direct and absolute connection with the arguments' reasoning; only one of the conditions of the answer has to undermine the argument. It would be far-fetched to assume that nanobes are single-celled organisms. However, it wouldn't be far-fetched to assume that single-celled organisms' lack of a reproduction system, but ability to reproduce and constitute life anyway, would undermine the author's argument that a reproductive system is necessary to constitute life.
What if the petroleum formed from bacteria? Answer D being correct assumes that the bacteria in the earth's crust was there as a coincidence, and not as a possible source of the petroleum itself. Answer D could be true, and the argument that petroleum was formed by living material. Not plants or animals, but still an alternative explanation that could refute the geologist's counterargument to a counterargument. The wording is also insane.
The explanation for why B is wrong is inadaquete. Why would children necessarily be the main users of a recreation center? If it was a playground it would make sense, but its a recreation center. The age of its users should make little difference. This question is lame.
I picked D, but then felt E was stronger because I think its reasonable to equivocate "no consensus" with "differing moral convictions," but upon closer analysis, I believe a group can have differing moral convictions while still arriving at a consensus. Of course, it took me getting the question wrong to realize this, so the logic is somewhat based on what the LSAT decides is the wrong answer.
In this case, D is a stronger answer, as it is literally the primary belief of legal positivism.