Hey all. I'm just wondering how most people deal with statements with both Group 3 and Group 4 indicators. I realize that one can use either rule and be fine, but in practice do most people just stick with one rule? I find it makes more intuitive sense to use the Group 3 rule, and was wondering if there were any downsides to just sticking with using the Group 3 rule at all times when I encounter a statement with both indicators.
For example, in the following statement:
"There will not be a good show unless there are sophisticated listeners in the audience."
With the Group 3 rule, one would diagram as:
GS --> SL
because one is negating the sufficient (/GS), which turns it into GS. The fact that "not a good show" is /GS makes intuitive sense to me because not should mean /.
However with the Group 4 rule:
not a good show becomes GS
unless there are sophisticated listeners becomes /SL
and therefore
GS --> SL
because one is negating the necessary (/SL) and making the other idea (GS) the sufficient condition. However, this is where I always get tripped up, because I don't think it makes intuitive sense for unless to be a negation. Also, my mind makes me constantly think that "not a good show" has to mean /GS, so leaving it as GS is really difficult for me to intuitively grasp.
What do others think? Is it fine if I just stick with the Group 3 rule for every statement that has both indicators? Are there any cases where using the Group 4 rule would be better?
@ said:
@ If I understand correctly, you're looking for all MSS questions from PTs 1-35 that you can print out, right? If that's the case, then I think @ is pointing you in the right direction.
The printable e-docs are here:
https://classic.7sage.com/lesson/lr-drills-preptest-01-to-09/
https://classic.7sage.com/lesson/lr-drills-preptest-10-to-19/
https://classic.7sage.com/lesson/lr-drills-preptest-20-to-29/
https://classic.7sage.com/lesson/lr-drills-preptest-30-to-39/
Yes, that's exactly it, thanks JY! I wasn't looking hard enough, so I didn't realize that the LR drills went up to PT 79.
This'll definitely be much easier than using the Question Bank!