Can you someone please further explain why AC (C) is wrong? Please also let me know your thoughts on my explanations. Thank you!
P1: Public interest comprises many interests
P2: The broadcast media must serve all of them.
P3: Most TV viewers would prefer an action show to an opera.
P4: A constant stream of action shows on all channels is not in the public interest
C: The broadcast media should not have a constant stream of action shows on all channels because by doing so, it would not meet its obligations of serving the public interest (comprised of many interests).
https://classic.7sage.com/lsat_explanations/lsat-48-section-1-question-06/
A ) If broadcasters look only to popularity, then broadcasters won’t satisfy their obligations of serving the public interest.
B ) Posed a hypothetical situation. We don’t know how many artistic and cultural shows are already being contrasted compared to other types of shows nor do we know if TV shows are being broadcasted in the right proportions to serve the public interst. Therefore, we don’t know if the public interest is being/not being met.
C ) The question didn’t ask to extrapolate beyond the information in the argument, but to logically complete the argument. AC (C) could be considered an inference from the information given, but not a conclusion that logically follows. The stimulus also discusses what broadcast media must do, not what television producers should do.
D ) Artistic quality is irrelevant and not discussed in the argument. Popularity doesn’t imply no artistic quality.
E ) “Only” is too strong and limiting of a word. Action shows could be replaced by opera or any other type of show and would not serve the public interest.
Awesome, thanks everyone!! I contacted @ , and will hopefully hear from him soon. :)