Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Apply for Membership

What is the difference between an argument part question and method of reasoning question?I was wondering if someone can tell me any differences between the two question types above. I see that they are similar but, I don't see any differe…
Removing a question from scoring? Challenging questionIf a question is removed from scoring, does that help ALL of the test takers grades go up? Does anyone know for sure?
PT 32, October 2000, Section 1, Question 12, Weaken QuestionI was struggling with the correct answer (B) and (E). Obviously, (B) is correct, because it points out the assumption that the route that polar bear …
Weakening Question Problem Set 1 Question 2But why D? I had some difficulty with this particular question because it just felt like none of the answers were really weakening it. I am missing s…
Question Bank question? Video explanations?How do I get a list of all video explanations (or at least the available ones) in the question bank? When I click on the explanation it merely says "…

Hallstown Groceries – PF Question

yeshesvini Member

November 2017 in Logical Reasoning 113 karma

https://7sage.com/lesson/hallstown-groceries-pf-question/?ss_completed_lesson=1143

while i agree AC b is incorrect...still seems to be a perfectly valid argument to me....anyone care to parse this one with me?

validity of answer choice B

Show Related Discussions

Comments

thisissparta Alum Member

November 2017 edited November 2017 1363 karma

Hey! So it looks like that is, in fact, a valid argument. The Manhattan forum and LSAT Hacks website also seem to say the same.

(for reference, see here: https://www.manhattanprep.com/lsat/forums/q22-most-people-who-shop-for-groceries-t1513.html
https://lsathacks.com/explanations/lsat-preptest-32/logical-reasoning-1/q-22/)

It's basically affirming the sufficient, so it's certainly within the realm of valid arguments.

/Own a car --> /Drive

John /Own a car

--
John /Drive

or Register to comment.