Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Weaken question not flaw

kfhsznakfhszna Core Member

I believe this should be a weaken question not flaw. Manhattan says its weaken too. Besides, the right answer choice E is giving a new cause- that of not being extroverted as a person OVER astrology affecting them.

Comments

  • Matt SorrMatt Sorr Alum Member
    2239 karma

    Apologies if I'm missing it, but which question are you referring to?

  • kfhsznakfhszna Core Member
    21 karma

    PrepTest 3 - December 1991 , Section 2, Q# 2.

  • Cant Get RightCant Get Right Yearly + Live Member Sage 🍌 7Sage Tutor
    27809 karma

    The difference is often fairly arbitrary. You can turn any Weaken question into a Flaw question just by tagging “fails to consider the possibility that . . .” in front of each answer. So the distinction actually isn’t that important as long as you understand the question stem.

    Reasonable minds may can disagree, but I think the question stem is pretty explicit in indicating the correct answer should indicate the flaw.

Sign In or Register to comment.