PT23.S3.Q06 - a purse containing 32 ancient gold coins

Grace...Grace... Alum Member
edited January 2016 in Logical Reasoning 344 karma
http://7sage.com/lsat_explanations/lsat-23-section-3-question-06/
I had some reservations in choosing answer choice C. I was able to eliminate all the others so answer choice C seemed most likely to be correct, but I wasn't 100% sure. The reason is that the premise states "The purse of a trader in the city "would probably" have contained a more diverse set of coins." and the C uses more definitive word, "had been brought". I think we don't know for a fact that it 'had been' brought by the pilgrims. It is a speculation. Since it is only a speculation that the purse would probably have contained a more diverse set of coins. I would think the correct answer would say "The purse... was probably brought . . . by a pilgrim."

Comments

  • c.janson35c.janson35 Free Trial Inactive Sage Inactive ‚≠ź
    2398 karma
    I see your reservation with C, but we are only trying to offer support for one of the hypotheses. So, just because the information we have doesn't 100% prove the hypothesis doesn't mean that it isn't supported by it.

    We know that the coins were from Morrocco. We also know that the city was a popular stopping point for travelers coming from Morrocco and going to Mecca. So, we can think: why would there be a purse of Morroccan gold coins inside the city? Well, there's 2 clear ways:

    1. A trader in the Jordanian city had the coins in his purse because it's an important trading stop.

    2. A Morroccan pilgrim brought the coins there.

    But we have 2 clear scenarios, so how could we make a hypothesis about just one of them?....

    "The purse of a trade would have probably had a more diverse set of coins."

    Cool, so this makes the first scenario more unlikely! It virtually eliminates the first possibility, leaving only the second. Thus, a hypothesis that looks like number 2 would be supported, which is what C says.

    How do we know this is most supported? Well, you've eliminated all of the other answers! And this is the only one with any support.

    Hope this helps!
Sign In or Register to comment.