Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories

Question on chain inference.

Yunny___Yunny___ Core Member
in Logical Reasoning 12 karma

Hello,

I know that iA —most→ B → C, then you cannot conclude most A are C. But if it becomes:

A —most→ B → C→ D

can you conclude that most A are D?

Question on logical reasoning
  1. A —most→ B → C→ D Conclusion: Most A are D.14 votes
    1. Valid Conclusion
      57.14%
    2. Invalid Conclusion
      42.86%
Show Related Discussions

Comments

  • kgarciarojaskgarciarojas Live Member
    50 karma

    Most the As are C, over 50% of set A is B, and that means that if all b are c, then most your As which are Bs are also Cs. So 50% of your As are Cs too, possibly more because most is more than 50%. Why do you think the two conditionals are different, one just has an extra the logic is the same.

  • James WeinerJames Weiner Alum Member
    42 karma

    I have a bucket of A, I pour most of it into a bucket B, I pour the entirety of bucket B into bucket C, then I pour all of bucket C into bucket D. Most of my bucket A is in now in bucket D

  • 1stWorldProblems1stWorldProblems Live Member
    715 karma

    Of course not, A could account for 1% of D, you don’t know how big of the circle C and D is.

  • DexterityDexterity Core Member
    edited September 15 934 karma

    If A-most-B > C > D, then A-most-D is a perfectly valid conclusion to make, as is A-most-C.

    Whoever said/voted otherwise needs to review this lesson: https://7sage.com/lesson/most-before-all-formal-argument-5/

  • 1stWorldProblems1stWorldProblems Live Member
    715 karma

    sorry I miss read it’s Most A is D, read that as most D is A. Yep it’s valid.

Sign In or Register to comment.