Failing of Sufficient Condition, etc.

Comments

• Cant Get Right Yearly + Live Member Sage ⭐ 🍌 7Sage Tutor

  November 2016 27899 karma

  @generationhar said:
  Is my understanding correct?
  

  You got it.
• steve-10 Alum Member

  November 2016 192 karma

  For what it's worth, rather than "the rule becomes obsolete" I like to think, "the arrow disappears."
  
  The arrow represents the rule, the logical relation between the the two conditions. For me, "the arrow" is more concrete than "the rule". When the rule is embedded in a chain of rules, such as "A --> B --> C --> D", thinking of one of the arrows disappearing makes the change clear. In the example, suppose we learn that B is false. The sufficient has failed for the B --> C rule, so that arrow disappears, leaving us with A --> B; C --> D. For me, this is easier than drawing consequences from "B --> C is obsolete."
• nessa.k13.0 Inactive ⭐

  November 2016 edited November 2016 4141 karma

  @generationhar said:
  If the necessary condition is satisfied, then the rule becomes obsolete because the sufficient condition can or cannot occur.
  

  Yeah, the sufficient condition can or cannot occur so the rule falls away.