Mismatched premise. (A) says that a certain outcome happens sometimes (library books you want are sometimes checked out), not that the outcome is guaranteed in every case.

The stimulus operates by claiming that we should not take a positive action (preventative maintenance) to delay a certain negative outcome (car trouble) because that outcome is guaranteed to happen eventually.

Mismatched premise. (C) says we should not take a certain preventative action (reinforcing bridges) because a negative outcome (earthquake) is rare, while the stimulus operates by saying that we shouldn’t take a preventative action because the negative outcome is inevitable.

Mismatched premise. (D) says that a certain outcome is possible anywhere (any route can have traffic jams), not that the outcome is guaranteed in every case.

Mismatched premise. (E) is missing the aspect of certainty; (E) just says that an outcome (plants dying) is “likely.”