The other day I was in an advanced conditional reasoning live session; I believe @EricWang was leading it, and shared a great tip for quantifier logic. "All before some; we're glum," "Some before all; we ball." If someone remembers exactly what he said or how he explained it, and would be willing to tell me, that would be awesome. Thanks!

3

2 comments

  • EricWang Instructor
    Edited Yesterday

    Hey! I’m not sure why that 11/3 class’s recording isn’t up yet… I’ll message someone if it’s still not up by 11/10 🙇‍♂️ Sorry!

    The mnemonic is used for linear quantifier conditionals: A -> B -> C

    If a “some” statement is on the A -> B, then you can infer a “some” statement between A -> C

    But if a “some” statement is on the B -> C, then you CANNOT infer a “some” statement between A -> C

    So, that’s why “some before all, we ball (can infer ✅)” and “all before some, we’re glum (can’t infer ❌)”

    If you want the actual reasonings and not just some silly shortcut, take a quick read here: https://7sage.com/lessons/foundations/logic-of-intersecting-sets/some-before-all-formal-argument-4

    Note: this is just for linear inferences, not for the “triangle” inferences that we talked about, like if A -> B and A -> C, then “some” B -> C

    Let me know if you have any questions!

    3
  • Friday, Nov 6

    Do you remember the date of the class? If so, maybe you could check for the live class recording?

    1
You've reached the end of the comments.

Confirm action

Are you sure?