Hi all! I had a question regarding the "skill builder: arguments" section of the lesson library.
Here, we say that the following is not an argument:
Human communication is a universal phenomenon that has existed across different civilizations over time. Linguists have conducted many comparative analyses of traditional languages from various regions and eras.
To me, however, I initially rejected the soundness of the passage's "argument"—mainly because the first sentence uses "universal," which is too strong of a qualifier—based on the second sentence. However, for linguists to conduct comparative analyses on traditional languages from various regions and eras directly implies that human communication is a phenomenon (even if not universal) that has existed across different civilizations over time.
I asked Sage AI, and it said the passage would be an argument if it were to directly tie the sentences together with a connecting word, such as "therefore":
Linguists have conducted many comparative analyses of traditional languages from various regions and eras (premise). Therefore, human communication is a phenomenon—even if not necessarily universal—that has existed across different civilizations over time (conclusion).
Maybe I'm overthinking this, but I wanted to set my logical reasoning straight before trying to dive into the other passages. Thanks!
1 comments
Hi there! While adding a "therefore" to that argument would make it technically an argument, you're right that it wouldn't be a very good one. The first version isn't an argument because there's no claim that one of those statements supports the other; it's just two sentences about vaguely related things, but we don't know which is supposed to be the conclusion, or if either of them are supposed to support the other at all. That would be like if a stimulus said "All clouds are grey, and the sky is usually blue unless there are clouds in it. When it rains, there are almost always clouds in the sky. But sunshowers can occur when the rain blows in from elsewhere. In fact, sun snow can also happen when snow blows in from nearby without clouds in the sky directly overhead." That's a big long sequence of claims, but none of them support the other to create a conclusion. They're just all vaguely related facts, which is what's happening in that first version of the argument.
In the second version, after adding "therefore" and changing the order a little, there is an argument, because now the author is claiming that a premise supports a conclusion. They are saying that "X is true because of Y," and that's an argument structure. To be clear, it would still be an argument if we did use the universal language. It just wouldn't be a very good one, and this is sort of similar to what we see in some necessary assumption and flaw questions: an argument that is technically an argument, since it argues that a premise supports a conclusion, but the actual argument is super weak and filled with holes/problems.
So if we changed up the language just a teeny bit, even less than 7Sage's AI did, this would be an argument: "Human communication is a universal phenomenon that has existed across different civilizations over time. We know this because linguists have conducted many comparative analyses of traditional languages from various regions and eras." That's an argument! The author says that something (sentence 1) is true because of something else (sentence 2). Again, it's a really bad argument. "Universal" is way too strong, and there's no way we can prove that just because linguists have done some studies about various regions and eras. But it is still an argument. Arguments can be bad, flawed, etc, and still be arguments, as long as the author claims something (conclusion) based on/because of a set of other claims/facts (premises). Hopefully that helps!