- Joined
- Dec 2025
- Subscription
- Free
Admissions profile
Applications
Discussions
I'm seeing different explanations for this answer, but in my opinion, it simply boils down to this:
Junkyard example (specific) is used as evidence to make a broader conclusion: because older cars are harder to sell to a junkyard due to the value of their parts, they must be harder to sell IN GENERAL because of their parts. Unless you assume that generally speaking, how well a car can sell is related to the value of its parts, then the junkyard example doesn't support the conclusion, since the conclusion is much broader than a junkyard.
Just because you will have trouble selling older cars to a junkyard, does NOT make it generally true that you will have trouble selling your old car. Maybe you can sell your old car on facebook marketplace for a lot more to a collector, or someone who rebuilds cars.
No. When you see “only if”, you treat it as a necessary condition, but not the only condition. So if something can happen “only if” something else is true, that means the condition must be true for the thing to happen, but that condition by itself isn’t necessarily enough to ensure the event will happen.
@BennettBlake E would be correct if this were a Necessary Assumption question ("What must be true?"), but rather, because this is a SA question, we're looking for an answer that connects the premise to the conclusion. E does not do this, because that info is already provided in the stimulus. E is only a trap if you mistake NA and SA questions, so you just have to keep careful attention to what the question is actually asking.
@EmilyB450 Also, another thing I've noticed during my studying is that "call attention" has a very specific connotation. Usually, it means the author is advocating for something, which is clearly not what is happening. The author is just describing these two concepts and the economists' struggle with them.
@EmilyB450 I would argue railroads are a "recent" industry since they only came about in the 1800s, not before. So that's why I found "increasing" to be acceptable verbiage in this question. But if not C, D must be correct because if it supports the Pin Factory, then it must anti support the Invisible Hand ("These two concepts, however, are opposed to each other"). Also, the specific "shortcoming" in question is that the Invisible Hand does not adequetely address increasing returns clearly existing in industries. Despite that though, I think your explanation about "increasing" is actually the right way to think about it. I had to interpret railroads, but if you think about this literally, you're correct. There's nothing about the Pin Factory increasing in industries, only maybe that the belief in the Pin Factory is increasing.
If this helps anyone, I find that the strongest textual evidence is this: "However, to determine the pervasiveness of the LHB, scientists will need to locate many more such rocks and perhaps obtain surface samples from other planets in the inner solar system." Therefore, the right answer must be some kind of evidence that addresses at least one of those points (locating more rocks and surface samples of other planets). Choice A is a sample of Mars, and if there is little evidence of intense projectiles hitting Mars, then it supports that the LHB did not occur outside of the moon and Earth. D doesn't as strongly support the question assertion because firstly, it's not a new rock or a sample of another planet, and secondly, it only addresses what the author called a "tiny" piece of evidence. While I can see being split between A and D, A is simply a stronger affirmative answer that covers exactly what the above quote demands.
@TuliaPfeffinger I think none of the choices are explicitly supported by the passage. Taking this into account, I think D is right because one must interpret the meaning of "profound consequences for the history of Earth". It makes sense that scientists are interested in the history of the Earth, and because a potential event could have profound consequences on it, scientists must be interested for that reason. All the other choices have no implicit support in the passage. While the answer could be stronger if the passage explicitly said that scientists care about the history of the Earth, it must be interpreted and inferred instead.
@alexfbaird Yes exactly! Doesn't matter if it was mentioned in the stimulus (usually it's not), just that it weakens the connection between the premise and conclusion.
Picked A and was wrong. But I think the bottom line here with these NA questions is that you're looking for the option that breaks a connection between a premise and the conclusion if negated. In this case: Jungle was too difficult to traverse, therefore used boats. But why are boats better than the jungle (land)? Because they must be easier. If they are just as difficult as the jungle to traverse, than the premise that jungle is hard serves no purpose and doesn't lead you to boats. I picked A because I was looking at this too much like a weakening question. If A is negated, it might weaken the conclusion that the dogs must have traveled between these two regions, but that doesn't actually break the argument completely. The premises still lead to the conclusion regardless.
@cclarez61 I actually disagree that E is stating a flaw in averages. It's stating that those who are offered big savings will switch, and those who are not offered that will not switch. Therefore, to say most people with other companies will save hundreds by switching would be based on a probably unrepresentative sample, because the survey includes new switchers who may have switched because of big savings, but in reality, is excluding those who probably would not switch because they would not save an average of $250. Maybe only 20% of all those with other insurances would save an average of $250, but 80% might save like $10 or not save at all. Therefore, the survey sample would include that 20% because they would switch, and not the 80% because they never switched. So you're basing a conclusion addressing most other policy holders on a survey that might only represent a minority of other policy holders. Overall, the flaw is that the evidence is not representative of the group addressed in the conclusion.
@Great1720 No problem! Yeah, POE is super important. But even with that, it’s important to also understand what makes the correct answer correct for this question type. So next time if you see a question like this, if you’re stuck between two answers after POE, it’ll help you pick the right one. I’m glad I could help.
@Great1720 If you don't understand how B is correct, you may not have identified the gap. Look at it like this: Chimps who show affection will be defended by those whom they showed affection to. Humans, similarly, will protect those whom they have feelings of affection. Wait... that's not saying the same thing. Chimps show affection for others and get defense in return, but humans feel affection and defend those who they feel that for. If you notice that these are not the same thing, you found the gap. The gap is that, how can we say chimps and humans are similar in this regard if chimps get protection in return for affection but humans give protection because of their own affection? Well, B states that chimps will reciprocate feelings of affections, at least sometimes. If we assume that, now it makes sense that chimps and humans are similar. Chimps do actually defend those who they feel affection for, because they are reciprocating the feelings of those who they are defending. Now the gap is filed, and it makes sense to conclude that humans and chimps are similar in this regard.
If this helps anyone, I wanted to point out that while the explanation for B being wrong is correct, I actually eliminated it because police interviewers are not trying to elicit "alibis" per se, they're trying to maximize information so "they" (the police, not the eyewitnesses) can confirm or disconfirm alibis. The alibis are not necessarily what police are trying to get out of interviewees, they're trying to simply get "information" to "confirm or disconfirm" alibis, not alibis themselves.
I'm just not convinced by C. Normally with these types of questions, the principle should lead you to the conclusion. Simply saying that the motive determines justification doesn't say that the particular action in the stimulus is justified, only that motive (whatever the motive may be) makes that determination. The answer doesn't go far enough in my opinion. The only explanation I can think of is that the question asks which principle helps to support (not necessarily justify) the argument, which may have implied that the correct answer did not need to 100% justify anything, only to lend support.
@Holly33333 I agree with this. I think that "flexible" comment is the only textual support for this answer choice without requiring assumptions.
@alexfbaird It doesn't have to. All E is really saying is that the analogy the professor gives is flawed because lottery tickets and insurance policies are fundamentally different (and it provides a reason why: "well being"). Therefore, it weakens the argument because it weakens the only premise.
@Zanderantochow While this question is annoying, I find that it is quite rare. With that being said, I can see why the answer is E, I just don't agree with the 7Sage explanation. A better explanation is that the passage is simply far too long to fit on a brochure, and is a bit too academic for a brochure. I have more issues with the explanation than with the question itself.
@mpglover Same boat as you when it came to narrowing down, but I picked E. Ultimately my choice was, even though I cannot say with certainty if pA author would view it as a success, saying that "political influence of women" is a current trend of scholarship is mostly unsupported. pA says the trend is away from women in particular and more toward gender relations (men, women, and the structures that relate them to each other). It never claims that the trend is toward the "political influence of women", and if anything, it would be a trend away from that and toward a more gendered view. My choice just came down to comparing the flaws in both C and E and deciding which flaw is worse. "Successfully" could have different interpretations (perhaps it just means that pA author would think using gender successfully achieved its stated purpose in pA, which it did). I couldn't really explain away "political influence of women" as well. I hope this makes sense.
I think the explanation for answer choice A is not fully encompassing. I would argue that Alex never makes this assertion, as Alex never says "most", and also "investors" does not imply owners. Therefore, Alex doesn't clearly address this assertion one way or another.
@EmboldenedJoyousMembership For a RRE (Resolve, Reconcile, or Explain) question, your goal is to not find a 100% full proof explanation for the results and try to poke holes in the answer choices. You're looking for the answer that simply could explain an unexpected result in some way. Unclear questions could indeed explain why a minority of the test subjects got the shading question wrong, perhaps because the question was misunderstood. Of course you could find a way to say that answer choice is not strong enough because "how does that mean the test subjects got it wrong? They could have still understood the question if it wasn't completely clear.". But that is not what the question is asking of you. Any explanation that could be plausible to explain unexpected results would meet the bar of "help to explain".
I misunderstood D but still picked A. Let's suppose you read D as saying that anti-environmentalism is actually the prevailing position. I would still argue that it is not strongly supported because just saying environmentalism is not politically orthodox and anti-environmentalism is not a dissenting view does not automatically indicate the reverse. It's possible that it is a 50/50 issue and neither side are "renegades" or "prevailing". It could just be a controversial issue, and the stimulus does not strongly support the reverse of what it is saying.
@jy1297 I agree with your explanation about "any" including hypothetical governments or governments yet to exist, whereas "no government" could only be referring to past and/or current governments. I think that is a more compelling explanation for "no government" to be a subsect of "any government". Regardless though, I cannot figure out a guaranteed way to not get a similar question like this right in the future, other than just being super careful with wordage and allowing some interpretation.
I'm not sure if anyone else will find this helpful, but I wanted to share a confusion I had and how I resolved it.
I initially misunderstood "only if" to mean that not increasing costs was the only condition that needed to be met in order to convert from a paper version to an online version. Because of that, I treated it as a sufficient condition.
What helped me was realizing that "only if" is inherently exclusionary. When someone says that an action can occur only if a certain condition is met, they are really saying that the action cannot occur if that condition is not met. In this stimulus, the treasurer is effectively saying that the journal cannot switch to an online version if doing so would increase publication costs.
That exclusion is what makes the condition necessary. The statement is identifying something that must be true before the conversion can occur, but it is not saying that the condition alone is enough to justify the conversion.
To see the difference, imagine the word "only" were removed and the treasurer instead said, "We should convert if doing so will not increase costs." That version is permissive rather than exclusionary. It tells us that avoiding increased costs is enough to justify converting, making it a sufficient condition.
What finally made the distinction click for me was focusing less on the word "only" itself and more on what the statement is doing. Is it excluding a possibility if a condition is not met, or is it permitting an outcome when a condition is met? Exclusion points toward a necessary condition; permission points toward a sufficient condition.
@bappel I agree that this sounds circular. But I would assume the explanation is that the "difficulty with modeling a particular economic assumption" is that the math involved is difficult. It's not really saying the math is hard because doing the math is hard, although honestly, it really does sound like that. In my opinion, the paragraph doesn't actually explain the difficulty in any meaningful way, only stating that the math is difficult. If it had elaborated a little more as to why, then I think the answer would be more clear.
This is understandable, but it comes down to this.
While we know what is sufficient to make a government action justified, there could be other things that justify a government action. Just because A does not meet the stated sufficient condition, it does not mean the action is unjustified. The government can be justified for other, unstated reasons. A could only be correct if the conditions in the stimulus were necessary, not sufficient.