- Joined
- Apr 2025
- Subscription
- Free
Admissions profile
Discussions
Would it be fair to say that for an answer choice to explain the discrepancy in the stimulus, it needs to help explain both why the demand is increasing and why deficiency has increased as well? In other words, an answer choice like C that explains why the demand is increasing but does not explain why the deficiency is increasing is incorrect because it explains only one side of the topic. Can this be a good approach to resolve/reconcile/explain questions?
#help
I understand why all other answer choices are incorrect. But I cannot see why D is any better. If the premises in the stimulus are true, shouldn't it be true that the temperature at any point on top of the stratosphere should be higher than the temperature at the top of the troposphere directly beneath that point? It is not enough that the two be at least equal. After all, if the temperature increases upward from troposphere, the top of stratosphere should have a greater temperature but not equal.
#help
Can someone please confirm that the only way A supports the conclusion in the stimulus is by confirming only a part of that conclusion? I think A only underlines that yes, indeed nations largely get their wealth from using their national resources. However, this only helps the idea that nations get wealth from the usage of natural resources BUT this does not directly help the part of the argument that this wealth is needed to sustain policies that brought about these improvements.
I think beyond this, what A is doing is responding to possible criticisms of the people about whom the columnist is talking about. One might raise the point that well, we can have more restrictive environmental regulations and have even better environment and still get the wealth we need from trade or taxes on imports. A, here, basically says that despite other avenues of income, nations still largely get their wealth from the exploitation of natural resources.
#help (Added by Admin)
Can someone please tell me how I can improve on this? I initially thought that the flaw was in saying that a measure should not be taken because it is would not rectify the main cause of a problem but I realize now that this is wrong. How can I avoid mistakes like this in the future.
#help
I think one has a better chance of getting this question right by process of elimination than actually understanding why E is right.
I think a simpler way to explain the answer to this question is:
The argument presents two methods to quit smoking: method 1 (hatha + counselling) and method 2 (self-help + counselling). The conclusion is simply that method 1 works! The premise offered for this is that method 1 works as much as method 2 does. For this premise to hold the conclusion, it must absolutely be true that method 2 must work (answer choice C) because, again, the argument says that method 1 works cause method 1 is just as good as method 2. Therefore, it is necessary that method 2 work as well in order for this comparison to support the conclusion.
Answer choice A is wrong because it is simply irrelevant. If the argument had said instead that "method 2 (self-help + counselling) is more effective than method 1 solely because of the self-help aspect of it", then, it must absolutely be true that individual counselling did not help at all (as answer choice A says). In that case, A would be correct and a necessary assumption.
Can we also argue that ac C mistakes a necessary condition (not catering national officials) as a sufficient condition for serving the interests of the locals? I think the stimulus is saying that it is necessary that in order to serve the interests of the locals you must not cater to national officials but it does not establish it as a sufficient condition whereas ac C's use of "only by" sort of confuses this relationship?
#help
Perfect explanation. The confusion was me not knowing tadpoles are immature forms of frogs.
Can someone please explain how the second argument does not contend that there is a link between humans and frogs? When I read the passage, the second argument by Dr. Grover replaces the DNA link between lungfish and frogs by the hemoglobin link between saltwater fish and tadpoles. I thought here the second argument is implying that the link is between frogs and lungfish is unreliable and instead offers a different link between two other species. Can someone explain how exactly the second argument uses the frog-lungfish to start its argument?
#help
Can someone kindly please check my logic chain based on the passage?
RL=restrict liberty
W=wrong
H=harmful
RL → W
RL → H
/H (offensive publication)→/RL
Inference: If something is not harmful (e.g. a publication that is only offensive) → Govt. must not restrict
#help
For question 28, the second part of AC B is down in the passage BUT how can we logically attribute it to the experts of line 32? The idea about exception for academics is provided by the author. The experts of 32 do not say anything about what the law must do for academics. Therefore, how can we infer that they would be ok with academics being given exceptions?
Answer choice E although not perfect is more in line with these experts' strict opinion of the law as expressed in the lines 32-36.
#help
The phrase "all but" has two completely contradictory meanings: "very nearly" and "all except". This is not fair!
Hey I don't know if you would agree but I thought E was wrong not because of the word "movement" because a campaign (like the Piko campaign) is a sort of movement but because it talks about about the effects of unionization on ethnic communities of immigrant derivation. There was no more than one community that is talked about in the passage and the primary passage has to do only with Pico workers' campaign and the effect it created. So the main purposes can't logically be ended to the effects of unionization in more than one community.
Can someone please explain why for number 1 C is incorrect. The passage says that the text was "not totally ignored" which implies it did some receive attention. It also goes on to describe that an author (Wright) gave it a bad review. So how could it be that "it did not receive critical attention" as E says. C does not look totally correct to me but it seems less wrong than E.
Hey, thank you so much for your help. I can better see why C is right when I take the meaning of "degenerative brain disorder" as it is implied in the stimulus. However, I am just shocked a little because I never saw LSAT writers use a term with such an obvious negative connotation (that disorder might lead to death) to imply that it will lead others to live longer which is positive. In my brain and I am sure in many others', this term clearly meant something that would not be conducive to longer life. It is like taking the word "beautiful" which has an obvious meaning and use it to mean ugly. I don't know what to do for the future but I guess I'll try to be more flexible with the implied meaning of words.
Yes, me too and also in the answer choices. I thought the bird was already in vegetation which is its safe spot and if it is flying away from it, then there must be a reason so I chose B.
I am genuinely confused. Doesn't degenerative brain disorder mean that the brain is more likely to fail and so the portion of people with this disorder in the population will be lower?
#help (Added by Admin)
I think there is another flaw that J.Y. did not notice in the argument. The argument draws a connection between the two different phenomena (supporting conservative candidates and supporting candidates who voted X) which is also unwarranted. This is in addition to the flaw of making a most inference out of two most inferences.
I understand why answer choice D is the right answer. However, when I look at my own diagram, I notice that the conclusion I drew was DC → RP (when duties conflict then rights prevail). That's why I got tripped because for answer choice D goes from BR → RP (if basic rights then rights must prevail) and that neglects the DC part. I was looking for DC somewhere in the answer choices. Can someone please explain if my conclusion was correct? I do not understand how and why the stimulus in the video does not draw DC as a part of the conclusion.,
#help