User Avatar
StudyorBust
Joined
Apr 2025
Subscription
Free

Admissions profile

LSAT
Not provided
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
Not provided

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT157.S1.P2.Q9
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Wednesday, May 29, 2024

Exactly. In fact, the passage says "in large measure it is an article of faith" with implies that it is to a large degree--but crucially--not entirely. The passage does not meet the bar of support to justify saying "no evidence."

0
PrepTests ·
PT158.S1.P2.Q9
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Sunday, Apr 7, 2024

I am in the same boat. I got the answer correct, but questioned it during BR and overthought it during the test itself as the racoon is does not seem to be analogous to anything.

0
PrepTests ·
PT158.S2.Q25
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Saturday, Apr 6, 2024

D is actually the inverse identical argument. If you take its contrapositive, it is the same argument expressed in the negative. Regardless, A isa better match, as it parallels the argument as is.

1
PrepTests ·
PT158.S2.Q22
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Saturday, Apr 6, 2024

I find that parallel flaw questions tend to be paralleling the flaw more than structure whereas regular parallel questions are looking for the structure to be paralleled.

13
PrepTests ·
PT158.S2.Q22
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Saturday, Apr 6, 2024

"Not as healthy as it should be" is not really an objective descriptive subset. It is a subjective description of the way something aught to be. Which is not exactly what we are looking for. This is a separate kind of error that we actually see a lot on the LSAT--usually on SA questions. One cannot make a statement about the way something "should be" from a set of facts without a sufficient statement that explicitly links the set of facts to a "should" statement... as the bridge to the conclusion of what "aught to be." Formally, this flaw is taking what is know as a normative conclusion (value judgment) from non-normative premises.

1
PrepTests ·
PT151.S2.Q15
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Wednesday, Apr 3, 2024

I understand that sufficiency and necessity are concepts we generally relegate to conditional logic, however, their idea is not exclusive to formal conditional logic. Technically, saying most houses would have more than one apartment includes the possibility that they all have two. This is one of many possible explanations that would be sufficient to explain the phenomena in the stimulus. So the error can therefore be described as confusing an explanation that would be sufficient for one that is therefore necessary--which led the stimulus to make the false conclusion that this explanation is necessarily true. I do not understand why this is wrong.

#help

4
PrepTests ·
PT149.S2.P3.Q18
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Saturday, Mar 30, 2024

Exactly my thought process as well

3
PrepTests ·
PT149.S1.Q23
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Friday, Mar 29, 2024

I agree with everyone here. AC C required just as much, if not more assumptions that AC A. C requires we assume the specific acts were in someway unique. Perhaps they are specific acts that actually characterize a cruel ruler, such as collective punishment of families or arbitrary detentions and imprisonment. A could support the argument with the one assumption that having less documentation overall makes his entire history suspect--not just the fact that his enemies were biased. This assumption seems reasonable even, as the first part of their premise has to do with there being "little" documentation, showing that is grounds for suspect.

I can try and contort more assumptions to make C not as appealing. "less" is vague. Maybe it is only one document less, and that would not make his history relatively suspect. Perhaps also modern historians do think that other emperors histories are suspect even though they do have more documentation--but then why did they use documentation levels as a premise if it is irrelevant?

2
PrepTests ·
PT149.S2.P4.Q27
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Friday, Mar 29, 2024

E is wrong because "cooperation and nurturance" are NECESSARY for progress, whereas E states progress will lead to/cause "cooperation and nurturance." This implies that progress occurred PRIOR to/WITHOUT its necessary condition--which is obviously impossible--aside from being a different type of relationship than described.

2
PrepTests ·
PT152.S2.Q25
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Thursday, Mar 28, 2024

Here's another take on the reasoning behind this question...aside from the "part to whole" flaw. The stim. says that "because there is less demand, the junkyards do not buy it." All that provides us is the necessary condition of our general statement, which is that "harder to sell→ less demand (contrapositive of " that more demand→easier to sell"). Satisfying our necessary is not enough to tell us the sufficient is true--that the car will be harder to sell, which is our conclusion.

In that sense what we need is both a sufficient and necessary assumption: that "less demand" →"harder to sell." That is exactly what "E" gives us: demand is a sufficient indicator of salability.

D is incorrect not only because it does not bridge the gap, but because its negation would merely be that lack of demand would be offset by lack of supply. This would strengthen the assumption more than weaken it, as we'd be left with a net-zero difference while we know that newer cars are easier to sell.

1
PrepTests ·
PT152.S2.Q23
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Thursday, Mar 28, 2024

Right! "Some Not" means/is equivalent to "Not All."

0
PrepTests ·
PT143.S2.P3.Q19
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Wednesday, Mar 20, 2024

The use of the word "license" in question 19 threw me for a loop. Colloquially, licensed means given an official license by an authority. According to the Oxford dictionary, licensed can mean: "DATED: give permission to (someone) to do something. " Classic LSAC to use an archaic use of a word whose alternate, more commonly used definitions would make an AC incorrect.

11
PrepTests ·
PT141.S1.P4.Q23
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Monday, Mar 18, 2024

For 23 I would argue that answer choice C is equally compelling. The author of passage B mentions what would happen "ideally" when talking about land rights, which is the equivalent of saying what would happen in a wholly just (AKA perfect) world.

What am I missing?

#help

14
PrepTests ·
PT140.S4.P3.Q16
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Friday, Mar 15, 2024

I have strong feelings about AC A for question 16 being correct. The second paragraph proceeds by telling us that recent research has shown that rigorous training rather than innate talent accounts for superior talent...and does so BY studying those with superior talent and isolating them from the exact specifications of the activity they excel at. This implies that we definitely CAN tell where talent arises. The passage does not imply anywhere else that this would not be possible in other arenas. So while A might seem plausible, it is not backed up by the passage--and if anything, would be weakened by it. What am I missing?

#feedback #help

5
PrepTests ·
PT139.S2.P4.Q22
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Monday, Mar 4, 2024

My take on why AC "B" was incorrect for Q22: The question stem asks which one of the following the "passage states." While the passage does state that the intension of the regulation is to prevent lawyers from being paid disproportionately, it does not state whether (or to what degree) this would be successful. If this was a "most strongly supported" question, B may have been correct, but it is asking for something explicitly stated--which is only AC "A."

3
PrepTests ·
PT139.S2.P4.Q23
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Monday, Mar 4, 2024

I have the same question. Let me know if you find anything...

2
PrepTests ·
PT119.S2.Q10
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Wednesday, Feb 28, 2024

What I do not fully understand is, utilizing the negation technique, why would C also not work as a necessary condition? If we are to negate "C" it would read "The more hours one works in a week, the MORE satisfactorily one performs one's work." This statement would completely upend the premises that working hours that are too long could endanger peoples lives.

Is that what JY is trying to get at at the end of the video? That what I assumed was the negation was actually a polar opposite, and not a negation--as the answer could be made false by just making the statement not linear (i.e.: performance drops off after X amount of hours instead of every hour)?

#help #feedback

0
PrepTests ·
PT117.S2.Q25
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Wednesday, Feb 14, 2024

Another possible angle to explore why "A" is incorrect: even if the author did presume a "fad" was "genuine acceptance" his argument would still not fail based on his own flawed reasoning. Since a fad inherently dies out quickly, as the author explicitly mentioned it did--and the bicycle disappeared between 1817-1860--the author would simply say "the values at the biggening of 1817 allowed for the genuine acceptance of the bike in the form of a fad--the values changed at the end of 1817, so the fad ended--and then they changed again to allow genuine acceptance in 1860." In fact, that is what he said: "the values in society clearly changed between 1817-1860." So his conclusion would not contradict this argument.

This is the same line of reasoning that the author used to begin with. New technology is accepted or rejected solely based on a societies values.

This argument is wrong for the reason stated in "E:" values are not the only necessary condition for technology to be accepted/rejected.

Just because bikes disappeared after 1817 (whether accepted of not) does not mean values are the only explanation for this to have happened.

4
PrepTests ·
PT112.S2.P3.Q15
User Avatar
StudyorBust
Friday, Feb 2, 2024

#help While answer choice D initially seemed best to me, a part of the answer contains direct contradictory phrasing to the passage. The answer choice states "Behavioral and Physiological responses to major changes in osmolality...are hormonally influenced," while the passage in line 23 states that "compensatory responses are initiated when deviations from normal are quite small." How is the difference reconciled?

8

Confirm action

Are you sure?