- Joined
- Mar 2025
- Subscription
- Free
Tiara has 3 years of teaching experience in a wide range of subjects, including English as a second language to children and The Art of Acting to undergraduate students. She uses her entire breadth of teaching experience as a knowledge base for tailoring her LSAT tutoring on an individual basis to most effectively advance any student’s skillset. Tiara graduated from Southern Methodist University in 2018 with a Master of Fine Arts in Acting, and she is currently a professional stage actor in Los Angeles. She plans on attending law school in the fall of 2023. In her free time, she enjoys playing video games (especially in the horror genre), powerlifting, dancing, and anything with cute animals involved.
Admissions profile
Discussions
Hi there, 7Sage tutor here!
This is a MBF Principle Application question, so we're looking for a viewpoint that is inconsistent with the principle. The reason JY was able to eliminate C and move on quickly is because he had a strict conditional diagram of the principle to adhere to. The stimulus, diagrammed, becomes Interfere -> Prevent Harm to Others. Using formal logic, we know that 1) if we negate the sufficient, the rule falls away and doesn't matter anymore, 2) if we confirm the sufficient, we must confirm the necessary to be consistent with the principle, 3) if we confirm the necessary, the rule falls away and doesn't matter anymore, 4) if we negate the necessary, we must negate the sufficient to be consistent with the principle. Therefore, viewpoints that could be consistent with this principle are viewpoints that 1) have no interference, 2) have interference to prevent the harm of others, 3) have harm to others with or without interference, 4) have nothing to do with either of these variables. This means that the only viewpoint that could be inconsistent with our principle must have interference without the prevention of harm to other people, which is answer choice E. Answer choice C negates the sufficient, "should not be banned," and so, as soon as you see that, you know that the viewpoint will be not be inconsistent with the principle and is not the correct answer.
Hope that helps!
Best,
Tiara
Reduced occupational injury is the effect and the establishment of safety committees is the cause. There is support that existence of committees in all medium-large workplaces will reduce injury whether it's required by law or not.
Hi there, 7Sage tutor here!
Good question! It's entirely understandable to conflate those two words, but indeed, understanding them as two different things is crucial to identifying the right answer choice.
I believe there were two possible "how/why"'s for understanding them to be two different things:
1) "Resistance," outside of the way we might casually use the word, is also a medical term used to characterize an invulnerability to certain antibiotics, pesticides, etc. Rather than the colloquial use of the word, more easily confused with aversion, the writers were combining the context of pesticides + it killing the insects less often over time to refer you to the medical use of the word.
2) Honestly, the medical use of the word is the biggie, but if someone isn't familiar with the term, I think there's another way around confusing the words to mean the same thing: aversion means avoidance and/or dislike, and resistance means to fight against. Aversion denotes not coming into contact with the thing because you dislike it, whereas resistance indicates coming into contact with the thing and opposing it.
I hope that helps!
Hi there, 7Sage tutor here!
Thinking of SA and strengthen questions as having a similar general effect on the argument is correct (that is, making the argument better), but be careful not to group them together as the same type of question. When presented with a SA question vs a Strengthen question, our jobs are very different, and often the LSAT will pepper in Strengthen or Necessary answers into the choices for a SA question or vice versa. To avoid these traps, we have to get very specific about what the question type is requiring, and the difference lies in the degree of strengthening.
Degrees of strengthening, from least to most:
Necessary Assumption: this is a fundamental, unstated building block of the argument. Without it, the argument crumbles.
Strengthen: this makes the connection between premise(s) and conclusion stronger. There are probably still plenty of reasons the argument could be invalid, but a strengthening answer choice will make the conclusion more likely to be true.
PSA: this is a SA question phrased in terms of principle, and because it's phrased in principle, there is flexibility/vulnerability in using it to make an argument valid. You can think of the correct answer choice as something that will make the argument just shy of true validity
SA: this makes the argument valid. Airtight, word perfect validity.
I hope that helps!
Hi there, 7Sage tutor here!
C is incorrect because, like JY said, it's not the heart of the problem. In both passages, leaving narrative and emotional connection out of writing is the problem. Lawyers mimicking the writing style of other lawyers is not a problem in of itself - it's only a problem because of answer choice B. In analogy questions, we're looking to mirror the specific function of the thing that they give us (in this case, lines 6-7 of Passage A), and the specific function here is "the heart of the problem." Answer choice B would be more accurately characterized as "something that exacerbates/spreads the problem."
I hope that helps!
Hey there, 7Sage tutor here!
Your conceptual understanding of the flaw is totally correct!
I know it can be a headache to learn, but there are two reasons that JY and 7Sage uses mostly abstraction/symbolism in the explanations (I say mostly because in the curriculum and occasionally in answer choices, rules and justifications for quantifiers are explained in a similar way that you've used here). First, once you've mastered the logic and can do it quickly, it's much easier to be able to recognize a set pattern without the distraction of the variables in it. In a parallel or parallel flaw question, for example, we're looking for the skeleton of the question so that we can find a mirror skeleton in the answer choices. Skeletons by definition are the things underneath, the structure, the thing independent of the outside trappings. So, learning to recognize the skeleton in a way that is devoid of content, i.e. using symbolism/abstraction, is more accurate/reliable than using other methods. Second, as a product of accuracy/reliability, it's also faster than other methods.
Understanding the logic in a literal and applicable way is part of the process, and you've done that correctly here, so you're on your way.
I hope that helps!
Hey there, 7Sage tutor here!
Let's talk about each of these potential assumptions:
"What if the baboons are maturing way too fast/young and this causes a problem?"
This, of all the assumptions you brought up, is indeed an assumption we shouldn't necessarily make. Frankly, as a wildlife non-expert, I know nothing about appropriate maturation rates for animals, and so yes, there is a possibility that this could have detrimental effects. Though it is an assumption, it isn't one that is taken advantage of in the answer choices as a weakness, and so we can identify it in the stimulus as a potential weakness and then move on when it isn't utilized in the answer choices. My guess is that JY, recording this video after having analyzed the question and answer choices, knew that it wouldn't be of use as an exploitable weakness in the answer choices and made the choice not to make note of it. Great job having a critical mind when reading the stimulus, though!
"And what if there are already too many baboons? Or do we assume the baboons are an endangered species because they are on the reserve?"
The question isn't concerned with population control, so whether or not there are already too many baboons isn't relevant. The baboons being an endangered species as circumstance prior to consuming the garbage also isn't relevant. Now, if the stimulus had expanded the circumstances to include all or most baboons as consuming the garbage, instead of just the ones on the reserve, and then one of the answer choices had stated that baboons became endangered after having access to the garbage, where they weren't endangered before, then that would be a weakness.
"Couldn’t they just hop the fence into the reserve to eat the garbage even though they aren’t supposed to officially be there because they aren’t endangered? They never explicitly stated that they are part of the reserve. They just said they were on the reserve to eat the garbage..."
The use of the reserve is to establish a select group of baboons that are eating the garbage; whether or not they live on the reserve or travel there is irrelevant. Remember, all we're looking for is weakening the relationship between premise and conclusion.
I hope that helps!
Hi there, 7Sage tutor here!
The use of the word "all" doesn't make it too extreme, and in fact we need the word "all" for A to be strongly supported. Using the word "all" means that we've mirrored the same conditions in other countries that require safety committees for all medium-sized and large workplaces. If we only implement the same practices for some medium-sized and large workplaces, then the idea that we would see improvement is less supported.
I hope that helps!
Yes, that would also be possible as a correct answer choice. Having Happy -> /Isolated or Isolated -> /Happy is not the only option to create a valid argument. Had there been an answer choice that diagrammed as Happy -> Meaningful Emotional Connection or /Meaningful Emotional Connection -> /Happy, that would have been correct.
Hi there, let me see if I can help.
"[T]he stakes are stark" means that the stakes are clearly defined and binary. In context of the passage, it's saying that if we choose to talk about the issue in terms of ecosystem destruction (the way that the author of passage A does), then it's very "this or that" in terms of outcome: nature lives or nature dies. Binary. Clear cut. But the author of passage B believes that this isn't the correct way to look at the issue ("In actuality, introduced species present a continuum"). The author of passage B believes that the stakes are not clear cut/binary.
Hi there! Let me see if I can help.
We're looking to strengthen the relationship between the premises and the conclusion that the work in Department F subjects the workers to higher level of stress than in other departments. E is an answer that does not differentiate between departments. It establishes stress as present at the company, but we are no closer to our conclusion that Department F has higher levels of stress than the other departments.
Indeed, stress is part of the stimulus -- but we always accept the premises as true, and we are given in the stimulus the statement that medical experts consider stress to be the cause. So, this part has been established. We don't need to establish it.
C is demonstrating an absence of effect (the syndrome) + changing one variable (being in department F) = presence of effect (the syndrome). Playing with the relationship of cause and effect is a common way to strengthen or weaken an argument.
Hi there, 7Sage tutor here!
A pretense of objectivity would be a person attempting to appear a certain way (in this case, objective about the art that is written about), but that appearance is false. The critic is the one that claims Waverly to have a pretense of objectivity, and whether or not we assume a claim to be true depends on the question type and the role the claim is playing in the argument: for question types that call on us to critique and/or manipulate the argument, then we are allowed to assume their premises are true. In real life, this isn't necessarily the case, but on the LSAT, you can assume premises are true. However, in these question types, we can take issue with the truth of the conclusion or intermediary conclusion (and whether we are weakening, strengthening, describing a flaw, etc., this is done by looking at the link between premises and conclusion).
This is a MSS question, and we do not need to scrutinize the actual argument. Our job is to take everything they say as true, whether it's an argument or a set of facts, and see which one of the answer choices can find support from the stimulus.
I hope that helps!
Best,
Tiara