- Joined
- May 2026
- Subscription
- Live
Admissions profile
Applications
Discussions
Okay I really hated this question at first - thinking I wold never get this question right, but after reading some responses and watching the video, its become much more clear and hopeful ill get a question similar to this correct next time.
The author uses correlational data to make the assumption that SL can reduce T. Fatalities.
I am going in this question with the prediction or idea, that the author is taking for granted that simply there could be other factors or reasons for the decrease in T. Fatalities.
I personally chose C - here is why its incorrect, first glance this seems to hit the nail on the head, except that the author is not taking for granted that there is a relation between speed and Accidents. He is making a relation with Fatalities. I don't need to explain to those studying for the LSAT why those two are not the same. You can also negate it for fun, there is not a relation between accidents and speed - does that weaken the argument > no, i can still think speed lowered fatalities.
I think A, B and D are easily eliminated by using negation tactic - Traffic has increased X Majority did not obey X ( Use of majority here is also crucial and common flaw to notice. New Speed limit is less enforced X.
So why is E correct? Let’s negate first, # of fatalities was abnormally high, so maybe the new speed limit did not decrease, maybe last year they hosted a national car race with 2 million drivers, and that caused many fatalities, but two years ago the speed limits was 65 and now its 64 and the fatalities have decrease significantly, why would a 1 mile change be the cause of that? You’re taking one data point of last year to make a conclusion rather than perhaps an average or aggregate from the past.
I would really love a proper explanation on why A is incorrect. Country X has more fat intake -> causes cancer. Country Y has less fat intake -> causes less cancer than X. The reason for different fat intake is varying “modifier” diet. A reasonable assumption would be diet, not fat intake is the reason for the correlation of cancer.
D is near the same level of reasoning, but it’s purely again correlation, More environmental pollution more cancer. But that takes a huge assumption to say it causes cancer. Maybe the other countries have no pollution while country X has one water bottle on Mount Everest.
it would make way more sense to attribute different diets than levels of pollution we have no comparison to in my opinion.
Hi I just want to clarify for others seeing this comment. Evaluate does not mean it must be the authors opinion - we do evaluate in P3 - even though we do not see an ounce of the author opinion till the last sentence of the passage in P4. In P3 Dworkin does evaluate the theory of legal positivism, and that would be sufficient if it asked what is a quality of p3.
In P2 although Dworkin is mentioned - he is not evaluating or critiquing - it says “Dworkin’s view is that legal positivists regard…” which is just an extended way of saying The legal positivists think X in Dworkin opinion.
The purpose of this passage it to break down the ideas for us to understand what legal positivism is, and then in P3 we follow up on why it does not work and what Dworkins new theory is.