- Joined
- Jul 2026
- Subscription
- Live
Admissions profile
Discussions
Aaaaah I was so close. I actually had E originally and was between that and D. I was able to eliminate A by reasoning that maybe the human cause here was a reduction in traffic, and B and C via POE too.
I thought that with D, if I negated it, that if something appreciably affects large scale weather patterns it is probably not cyclical, then that would weaken the argument considerably because it makes it less likely that the 7 day cycle could affect the weather.
My original reason for choosing E had been that it was about 7 day cycles and without that assumption you could have any number of days of cycles (so why the work week cycle then?). but after reading it again, I saw the "natural cause" part, which made me switch from E because I reasoned that the question was not asking about natural causes.
In hindsight, E was the stronger choice solely because D talks about something "probably" being cyclical whereas E is more certain. I also did not fully understand E and see that it eliminates natural causes of non 7 days length. So therefore I'm going to try and negate choices more and to fully understand them before I dismiss them, but it's hard haha.
I chose C because I was thinking in terms of inferences (although this is not a true inference question). C seemed justifiable because it's reasonable to think that by releasing without consulting anyone, you wouldn't learn about whether anyone had serious reservations. But in hindsight, I see that the condition A creates is necessarily not fulfilled (no one can give consent if they have not seen it), whereas the condition created by C is a hypothetical consideration to begin with.
I found B easy to eliminate because of the "even slightly" wording. The stimulus does not talk relative about levels of pesticide, and "even slightly" is just strongly worded imo.
I don't see why we can dismiss B so easily if we can accept D. You can easily assume that wealthy countries are more industrialized and thus prone to cancer similar to how you can assume that pollution leads to cancer. I do see how D is a little more direct, but when I did the question I saw both as hinting at the same thing, which is why I then chose E (oof).
I chose E because I thought that legal system was interchangeable with a punishment scheme, lol.
One way E is wrong that I didn't realize at the time is that it talks about increases in productivity. Yet the stimulus is about "high productivity." It's about a state of productivity that is high to begin with, and not about increasing productivity. I was in between B and E and had I realized that the stimulus was only saying that adequate training is necessary for high productivity, then I would have chosen B.
Also, I feel like this is a problem very easy to get wrong if you're interested in economics which always talks about productivity growth and not necessarily a constant state of high productivity.
same!! it didn't occur to me that lsat could ask you about the principle used by the 1st person in a 2 person dialogue
Why is "benefited from luck" equated to a requirement? I originally had A but I read "benefit" as a sufficient condition, so I ended up switching to B because I thought maybe that "anyone who has studied successful people" is the improperly authoritative source.
Did anyone else choose B because they thought 'offset' implied that it would cancel out, and then some? I was between A and B but I chose B because I read it that way and it seemed to attack Umit's point more directly than A. I also thought that A had the unreasonable assumption that pollution "a significant distance from major cities" wouldn't end up polluting urban areas. But I can see how A would be correct if you don't read B the way I did.
I was very stuck on this problem, spent close to 5 minutes on it, but I think what helped me arrive at B was that it talked about 'invariably' which I read as a mandatory condition, and it was easy to imagine a scenario where that was wrong. This was one of those questions where none of the choices made any sense to me.