- Joined
- Apr 2025
- Subscription
- Free
Admissions profile
Discussions
So people highly motivated to exercise don’t feasibly describe the participants in this study about exercise, but identical twins reading do?
The flaw in the argument isn’t that it is hypocritical by employing a sleazy tactic it itself criticizes, but rather that it states that that tactic causes the argument it supports to fail. If that is true, then the Commentator’s argument fails. If it is untrue, then the argument fails because its premise is untrue.
The problem I have with A is that it says “inability to cover all sides of any important story” instead of “inability to cover all sides of every important story.” We are looking for every important story to have all sides told, not just some, in order to satisfy the premise.
On second glance, the argument appears to work like this: because predatory pricing doesn’t lead to unreasonably high prices, it should be acceptable. E could work either as a sufficient or necessary assumption in this case.
Where did the stimulus say that all practices that don’t lead to unreasonable prices (not necessarily just predatory pricing) should be acceptable? It doesn’t. It is limited to a discussion of predatory pricing. E might be a necessary assumption for some argument, but not the one provided in the stimulus .
That is not the negation. When you negate “any,” you change it to “some.” The negation is some pricing practices that do not result in unreasonable prices should not be acceptable, which does not logically contradict the stimulus.
This is a NECESSARY and not a SUFFICIENT assumption question. How can this be glossed over? A must be true question is not a could be true question. If x then y does NOT mean if y then x.
An alternative reading to answer C is that tenants do not currently have an incentive to conserve electricity but landlords do. If we strip away this incentive by making tenants pay for their own electricity, we don’t know if tenants would then have an incentive to conserve energy, and we don’t know if landlords would either.
That’s just it, the answer choice doesn’t say that incentive will disappear. There is no formal, logical leap to that assumption.
The problem with answer C is it requires us to assume that landlords don’t have an incentive to ensure their tenants have energy efficient devices if they don’t have to pay for it. This is a reasonable assumption, but the LSAT is very arbitrary over which assumptions it will allow and which it will not.
A actually supports the argument that Caligula was a tyrant, because it provides an alternative explanation for why little documentation exists from his reign calling him a tyrant - little documentation of any sort exists from that period.
You don’t know that. The stimulus just says sphagnum moss is used somehow in the production of dried peat moss, and that sphagnum moss fields contribute oxygen into the atmosphere (more than the totality of rainforests.) Saying that this is a significant loss makes sense, but the test writers could just have easily made this a trap and thought of that as an unwarranted assumption.
A is definitely not “horrendously” wrong, and contains no error fatal to the argument. The exact opposite is true. B is only the better answer if you make the assumption that the depletion of sphagnum moss fields reduces oxygen into the atmosphere, which may jump out as obvious to some, but lacks textual support.
The stimulus does not say that the conversion of sphagnum moss to dried peat moss results in a moss that produces less oxygen, so an assumption that less oxygen is entering the atmosphere is unwarranted. Although A has little probative power, it is a necessary statement for the argument to be drawn.
The stimulus concludes that the public's fears of potential nuclear meltdowns are justified. This is in spite of the fact that the government claims that there is no risk of meltdowns. The government shields nuclear companies because it knows there is a risk of meltdowns. D points out that the government sometimes lies, and wouldn't take countermeasures unless it was acting in apprehension of a real risk. Bingo. C, once you parse out the verbiage, just says that eliminating immunity for nuclear companies is not in the public's best interest. That does nothing to complement the arguement or contradict it.
I think the saving grace of the correct answer choice was “reliably.” In spite of their best efforts, historians are sometimes unsuccessful in singling out a reliably correct date.
Exactly, this is a bad question bc it requires an unjustified assumption to find the correct answer. The fact that historians may try a certain method that is not always successful does not mean that they are left with only that imperfect option.
Malthus' argument is that lack of food will lead to war, famine, etc. The assertion that food production capacity outstrips population growth is something the author avers will eventually change, but this bare fact does not support Malthus' argument, because it says nothing about the consequences of food shortages, the other part of Malthus' position.
The Q22 explanation is such a “just so” story. Yes, eventually government involvement attacked those social ills, but where did the passage say that was necessary?
D is the right answer to Q21 because we know that the reproduction rate of the predator mite depends on its consumption rate, and the passage states that its reproduction (thus consumption) seasonally vary with the prey’s reproduction.
Why would we need the predator species after the prey species has been completely devoured? That’s the same line of reasoning as C, which was ruled out. Once the predator population has done its job, the passage suggests no reason why we would want them to stick around.
The “correct” answer to Q27 is an unsupported inference. While it is stated that C mites do not always cause significant damage, we are told nothing about the predator mites. The setup for the passage only refers to controlling pest populations, not ensuring the health of plants.
Except lipoproteins were not shown to cause heart disease. The prompt trapped readers into imagining that connection on the tenuous basis of recent findings that many people who had heart diseases unrelated to any other cause had above average concentrations of lipoproteins. On the basis of this statement, it’s possible that most people who had heart disease unattributable to any other cause had lower than average amounts of lipoproteins, making the association between the two negative, or for there to be no correlation at all.
The language of the prompt was that above average levels of lipoproteins have been found in many people who have heart diseases unrelated to any other cause. So what? It does not suggest that there was a statistically significant relationship between heart disease and lipoproteins. It would be like saying, recently many people who died in car accidents were above average in weight. B is only wrong because even if such a relationship existed between lipoprotein concentrations and heart disease, it wouldn’t negate the fact that diet can affect cholesterol which can affect incidence of heart disease. To reiterate, the argument presented no evidence of a link between lipoproteins and heart disease, but that was not a flaw in the argument, because it played no supportive role for the conclusion, it was just a dummy premise.
Also, saying something that is false is not necessarily lying. An honest mistake would also be morally wrong per the reasoning in the stimulus.